• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

One Bass to do it all?

I prefer to have different basses with different personalities. I don't have the need to have only one bass to every musical situation. To me, it's more fun to look to all my basses and choose one depending on the mission (Just like the assembly of a Mission Impossible squad).

Besides that, to play different basses make me a different musician as well because its ergonomics put me on different frames of mind (something that only one bass can't do to me). I like that.

I like having more than one bass and more than one sound. Maybe I should have said that I want is to be able to use my fretless in any setting. I want to get used to hearing that sound any time I play bass even if I choose not to use it.
 
Since I like to play fretted and fretless, and I have music associates who tune to standard A440 and others who tune down 1/2 step, I have 4. Cannot justify any more or any less basses as long as I enjoy doing this.

Since you have put some miles on the Carvin and the Sire, which one feels better to you?? Which one sounds better to you?
 
Of course, there's always the idea of changing strings, amp settings, and/or pedals to change things up with the Pedulla, Doc. Heck, with the right bass synth pedal you can make that sucker do train whistles to fog horns.
 
Though I have higher quality instruments in my collection, I always return to my passive 1971 Fender Jazz.
Why? Having spent years and countless hours on it, I have learned how to emphasize its strengths, minimize its weaknesses, and coax a myriad of usable tones out if it using a variety of hand positions, drop tunings and pickup combinations. Reggae, rock, country, pop, funk, jazz, ska, latin, gospel - it’s all in there with enough exploration. IMHO, it’s more about putting time into learning the intricacies of a given instrument than the make/model/features.
 
I like having more than one bass and more than one sound. Maybe I should have said that I want is to be able to use my fretless in any setting. I want to get used to hearing that sound any time I play bass even if I choose not to use it.
Fretless is a tough one to make work in any situation.

I'm tired of Versatility. It's the most overrated thing in buying a bass.
I'll be the first to say that versatility comes from the player, not the gear, but there are some basses that I have that are specialty basses and aren't the most versatile. I can make them work for anything, but it's a matter of forcing square pegs into round holes for certain things. I mean, I could use my violin basses for an 80's-90's hard rock band, but it wouldn't be the easiest thing to pull off.
 
Recently, I found that I had a hard time getting my Pedulla to sound the way I wanted it to when rehearsing for a church concert at the end of the month. My Sire really sounds great for the music, but it is bothering me that my main bass is not working out. Now that I know the songs better, I am going to practice them at home on the Pedulla and use my Pentabuzz at the next rehearsal. I think of how many great players have had careers on one bass, and I feel that I should be able to carry out my humble take on one bass too. In fact, I really want to let some basses go. Probably just keeping my Sire, Peavey Fury, and Pedulla. I do have another bass on an extended layaway and selling off my Carvin may take care of that. Four basses is still a lot of basses, but I want to use the Pedulla at least 75% of the time. If my Peavey had not only cost me $65, I would probably sell it too.

There is no one bass that does it all
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bassman013
Fretless is a tough one to make work in any situation.


I'll be the first to say that versatility comes from the player, not the gear, but there are some basses that I have that are specialty basses and aren't the most versatile. I can make them work for anything, but it's a matter of forcing square pegs into round holes for certain things. I mean, I could use my violin basses for an 80's-90's hard rock band, but it wouldn't be the easiest thing to pull off.

Maybe it is just dawning on me that my most expensive and well made bass may not be the most versatile bass I own.
 
I have not met a situation yet that an Ibanez SR5 can't handle. I also have a cheap SX SS jazz 4 string that can do justice to most situations that don't require you to change keys to suit different singers. My GAS has moved to amps now.....
 
Some come very, very close to covering it all.

Well you got short scale, long scale, 4 string, 5 string, 6 string, 8 string, 10 string, 12 string, fretless, fretted, round wound, flat wound, active, passive, single coil, humbucker, different tone woods, single pickup, dual pickup, vintage, modern, body shapes, neck profiles, colors, finishes, and more options not yet mentioned …

all of those options have inherent strengths and weaknesses

well I think I need more than one bass

and I can't forget tort!!!

edit … Hollow body and solid body, acoustic and electric
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Bassman013
One Bass to do it all?
Fender_Precision_Bass.jpg
 
Recently, I found that I had a hard time getting my Pedulla to sound the way I wanted it to when rehearsing for a church concert at the end of the month. My Sire really sounds great for the music, but it is bothering me that my main bass is not working out. Now that I know the songs better, I am going to practice them at home on the Pedulla and use my Pentabuzz at the next rehearsal. I think of how many great players have had careers on one bass, and I feel that I should be able to carry out my humble take on one bass too. In fact, I really want to let some basses go. Probably just keeping my Sire, Peavey Fury, and Pedulla. I do have another bass on an extended layaway and selling off my Carvin may take care of that. Four basses is still a lot of basses, but I want to use the Pedulla at least 75% of the time. If my Peavey had not only cost me $65, I would probably sell it too.

Sometimes, I have a set sound or tone in my head that I think the song should have before my bass has been played. It's really unhelpful (to me, anyway), because I usually play everything on my Fender Jazz.

If I chase the tone in my head on that Jazz, I might never find it. Especially if it's a modern humbucker type of sound. However, if I take a step back and stop being stubborn, my Jazz will give me a tone that fits the track. It may not be the original one I had in my head, but it ends up working out exactly as it needed to.

Some dudes need to always lay down what they heard in their head before plugging in. For me personally, I'm never truly satisfied if I give in to it. Let the bass speak, not your expectations.

My $0.02