What are the pros and cons of having one vs. two guitar players in the band and which do you prefer?
Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
One or Two guitar players in band?
- Thread starter BigMac5
- Start date
We have two (sometimes three), which is way too many in my opinion. I think one is the ideal number, unless you can have two that know how to complement each other and not compete with each other. You just don't need two guys playing full chords on most of the songs we play (actually none of the songs we play). How do you get the 'rhythm' player to just sit back every once in a while?
I think having one guitarist, if he or she is really good, can give you a good, clean sound and open up a lot of sonic possibilities. I think it is also easier to learn new songs and to get into jams with just drums, bass, keys and one guitar.
I think having one guitarist, if he or she is really good, can give you a good, clean sound and open up a lot of sonic possibilities. I think it is also easier to learn new songs and to get into jams with just drums, bass, keys and one guitar.
one guitarist if they are good. get them a loop pedal and you're set. Otherwise you have to get a rhythm guitarist and that just gets complicated/overkill sometimes.
Passinwind
I know nothing.
- Dec 3, 2003
- 23,087
- 46,069
- Disclosures
- Designer/Toaster Tech @ Passinwind Electronics
I hate when all the midrange drops out during solos. I demand 2 guitar players in my bands, not negotiable.
I've come to like my band's setup: 1.5 guitars. The singer plays on some songs, and not on others - sometimes only sparingly. It's great because when we need more, it's there, but there's no obligation to have 2 parts at all times.
Unless you have a keyboard player, I think a band really needs a rhythm player, although this depends on the material, too.
My band has a rock-solid rhythm player who is also the lead singer, and that frees our lead player to go to places he couldn't if he were the only guitarist.
My band has a rock-solid rhythm player who is also the lead singer, and that frees our lead player to go to places he couldn't if he were the only guitarist.
I prefer one guitar player.
If you had one that played rhythm only, and had the other one only play during the solo, then it might work.
I'm currently in a duo and we fill the sound out just fine(even during solos!)
But we are looking for a drummer. It would make some songs easier.
If you had one that played rhythm only, and had the other one only play during the solo, then it might work.
I'm currently in a duo and we fill the sound out just fine(even during solos!)
But we are looking for a drummer. It would make some songs easier.
Passinwind
I know nothing.
- Dec 3, 2003
- 23,087
- 46,069
- Disclosures
- Designer/Toaster Tech @ Passinwind Electronics
I'm dead serious, I greatly prefer keys and/or horns to guitar. But bear in mind that I'm not a rocker in any way, shape, or form either...
Anyhow, I vote less is more. If you gotta have 2, don't use 3, etc.
Love your hat Passinwind.
Check out this thread man......
http://www.talkbass.com/forum/showthread.php?p=4471283#post4471283
I voted for one
I think a band is much simpler and easy to write songs and jam with just one
and i know about the whole thing about the md range dropping out
but an ampeg overdrive pedal that adds a higher octave back in and gives you lots of distortion/mids
this only really works though if you are in a rock type setting
i doubt many funk bands could use this idea
I think a band is much simpler and easy to write songs and jam with just one
and i know about the whole thing about the md range dropping out
but an ampeg overdrive pedal that adds a higher octave back in and gives you lots of distortion/mids
this only really works though if you are in a rock type setting
i doubt many funk bands could use this idea
I play in two bands and both have two guitarists and one has three when the keyboardist feels the need. None of these guys fight or compete with each other and it works really well. They know how to complement each other and make it sound really good.
Having more than one guitarist allows the band to be a lot more creative than you can be with one guitar. Plus, having two guitars sounds so much bigger and badder than just one.
Having more than one guitarist allows the band to be a lot more creative than you can be with one guitar. Plus, having two guitars sounds so much bigger and badder than just one.
I think two is generally better than one. Especially where a lot of solo's are concerned. It can be quite difficult for the balls not to drop out of a song when a lone guitarist goes for a solo.
Although I do like this looper pedal idea. The only catch being you need a guitarist with a sense of rhythm and there's about two of those known to man kind.
In terms of writing music I find one is better since it allows me to breath a little and be more creative with my bass lines. Sometimes I find I have to scale them back a bit to leave space for another guitar, which can be unfortunate
The main disadvantage that I can see in having two guitarist in your band, is that you have two guitarist in your band
Radiohead use three guitarists and are a good example of how if done tastefully and right it can work very well. Granted three guitars aren't used on every song.
Although I do like this looper pedal idea. The only catch being you need a guitarist with a sense of rhythm and there's about two of those known to man kind.
In terms of writing music I find one is better since it allows me to breath a little and be more creative with my bass lines. Sometimes I find I have to scale them back a bit to leave space for another guitar, which can be unfortunate
The main disadvantage that I can see in having two guitarist in your band, is that you have two guitarist in your band
Radiohead use three guitarists and are a good example of how if done tastefully and right it can work very well. Granted three guitars aren't used on every song.
