P bass pickups poll

[BillyLebuA]

Hi guys

I did some researches on these pickups
1. Aguilar 4p60 HOT
2. EMG GZR P (Most popular)
3. Nordstrand NP4
I find them to have similar sonic character to my ears. I also like the tone of all of them.
But I have not found a thread which compares all three. So what are your thoughts on these for all around type of music?


Thanks for Any inputs guys

 

[sheltjo6]

I have tried the Geezer and the Nordstrand NP4. The Geezer has a pronounced mid frequency tone where the Nordstrand has a more hollow tone. I would not characterize these pickups as sounding similar. I have not tried an Aguilar Precision pickup, but a lot of bassists like their pickups.

I like the Geezer, but I'm tempted to try a Lauzon and Arcane Precision pickup.

Laurent has posted a few p pickup threads in this forum. He seems knowledgeable in regards to Precision pickups.

 

[jallenbass]

They are all great at what they do. They are definitely different from one another though. I chose the GZR but take that away and I would be very happy with either of the other two. I play in an original roots rock band with 2 female vocals, acoustic guitar, electric guitar, bass and drums.

 

[jallenbass]

I'll also add that if you are someone who only plays at home then most Precision pickups sound good. In a band setting the differences get sorted out pretty quickly.

 

[JimmyM]

I'll also add that if you are someone who only plays at home then most Precision pickups sound good. In a band setting the differences get sorted out pretty quickly.

Boy is that the truth!

 

[aproud1]

I think the Geezer is the most precision sounding of the three. As stated above the difference is especially noticeable in a mix.

Frankly P bass pickups really sound better to me in a mix. I like my p bass sound but with other instrument the magic happens.

 

[bassliner50]

Where are Duncan SPB-1 and Fender Original in this poll? Would be interesting to see how the masses rate these against those that are mentioned.

 

[Jefff]

While no longer fashionable, Lindy Fralin makes the best passive pickups I have ever personal heard.