Reviving this old thread...
I'm having a similar issue with my power tubes. The amp was making a resonance/buzzing sound with certain notes with my old set of power tubes. A few months ago, one of them burned out, so I bought a new set of matched power tubes (JJs from TubeDepot). Noticed the buzzing again. Today, I took off the spring tube retainers, but the buzzing persisted. When I tap the power tubes I get the same rattling/buzzing sound. When I tap the preamp tubes, nothing. Does this mean the power tubes are microphonic? Kinda frustrating this these are brand new. Should I ask for a replacement set of tubes?