• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Pj pickup advice

When I was putting together my P/J 5er I went with Dimarzio J and Fender P. A terrific sounding combo. And the P soloed really sounds like a "P". But be aware that they don't quite balance. The P is about 15%-20% hotter than the J. Some people overwind the J to compensate but I prefer to keep it all stock and just roll back the P volume a tad to get balance.

This is always the problem with P/J configurations. Getting a nice balance when both volumes are up full. The alternative is to get over or underwound pickups and then everyone complains that with pickups soloed they don't sound like a "real" P-bass.

Agree! - like this combo on my fretless. Just did this with a Franken' Franklin I pieced together. Model J is plenty hot enough though - just have it about 1/32 closer to the strings. Volume is balanced well with either solo'd. Some of us had phase issues with the Fender P and the Model J though. For me the fix was swapping the wires on the P side that had a phase issue. Here is final wiring diagram:

FrankenFranklinFinal.jpg
 
The two ideas that are common through this thread which I agree with:
1) the same make for both pickups so they coordinate; and
2) split-style J pickup so it is humbucking like the P.

One added detail: this may lower the output a hair, but mounting the J in the "70's" position will get more of a contrast to the P tone.
 
I recently put in an Aguilar PJ set and I am thrilled. Both pickups are very well matched for output and the J is split - dead quiet with either pickup at any level.

They sound great - very muscular and really shine in the mix. Solid lows, punchy mids and they can give you crisp if you want. I run mine passive V-V-T and roll off the tone about 30%. I use them mostly for R&R but they are very versatile. Big and clear support with a very "organic" (for lack of a better word) tone.

It's clear to me that Aguilar really put some thought into what could be a hit or miss combination of pickups. Still relatively new to the game, but they should be at or near the top of the list soon. Highly recommended.
 

Latest posts