• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Prototyping a new bass...with your help!

What makes a "cheap" instrument a winner with me?
I need a good, working bridge. Something that's not just adjustable, but that has a smooth string angle so that the strings don't break too easily. I used to swap out the bridges of my basses with Schaller roller bridges.

I also think the fret ends and the fingerboard edge is vital to a good feel. Make sure they are smooth and rolled off, that gives that slightly "worn-in" feeling.

Proper fretwork! I hate basses where the frets aren't levelled properly.

Satin finish on the neck.

Good sounding pickups, PJ configuration always looks and sounds sweet. And if you get a 3+2 Precision pickup in the neck position, I think that's the visually most pleasing :) But most importantly, get pickups that doesn't have to be swapped out and replaced by something decent by the buyer.

Do 21 frets, so you end on the E (not Eb) on the G-string and slightly alter the lower horn to give easy access to the last couple frets.

Balance... if necessary, prolong the upper horn to achieve good balance.

A tight neck route, and maybe use a 5 or 6 screw joint with inserts rather than neck plate.

Use a hybrid string spacing scheme (something in between Jazz and P, maybe 17.5 or 18 mm), but don't jump to 35" for tight B-string... in my experience, it's the build quality as much as the scale length that gives the tight B-string. And for a vintage instrument, people will be wanting their 34".

And do a proper setup before shipping. There's nothing quite as turn-offy as picking a poorly adjusted bass out of the box before playing it the first time :)

I think most of my points above could be achieved within the price point. I've played basses that came close, but they all lack that tiny little attention to the critical detail. Usually I can get most basses to play sweet for me with a couple hours of tender loving care... but I just don't understand why they don't spend that energy themselves before shipping them out. :)
 
If i could have a P bass 5 string to my liking here is what I would want.
Body: Swamp Ash/Ash
Strings are through body
Thumb rests were the best idea Fender did, and I have no clue why they never stuck to them. So one of those (or the option for one) in the late 70's P bass position is a thing I would personally like to see.
Finishes natural/Sunburst (something unique though, not the standard 3tone.) Olympic White, Black, Surf Green, Lake Placid Blue, etc. all in Nitro finish
Badass V Bridge (Or something that is equivalent mass to one that can be through body.)
Definitely needs an extra pickup, maybe a Humbucker EMG? Or maybe a J pickup infront and behind the P pickup? Just do something not P bass. Too many of them out there. Also make it passive/active.

Neck material, I personally would love to see, All Maple, Maple neck with Rosewood fretboard and an all rosewood neck. All with unlined fretless, lined fretless and fretted. (Obviously all rosewood isn't a must but I played an EBMM Stringray 5 that had an all rosewood neck and it played beautifully and looked really nice as well. So I thought it would be something worth considering that would make your P basses different from everyone elses?)
At least 22 frets.
Not sure on neck size, I don't have enouh experience with 5 string neck sizing so I would be of no use here.
Good easy to use tuners.
Neck finish in Nitro or Satin.

Hope this helps.
 
I agree that if I am paying a lot of money for a bass I expect the setup adjustments to be as good as they can be right out of the box.
Buying a new instrument that doesn't play well and has to be worked on as soon as it is purchased is like buying a new car and the next day having to take it somewhere for a tune up, oil change, and new tires.
Also, f your company already has a PLEK machine I would pay quite a premium for having my bass fretwork done correctly the first time using that technology, and it would be a tremendous marketing tool for you if advertised properly. If you could do that for $1200 ish I believe you would attract a lot of buyers. It potentially could be a great Fender, G&L and Lakland bass killer.
 
Fret work and set-up are paramount, yes. Going for the P sound, what would you look for in a preamp? Active/Passive of course, but are there things besides an EQ that are desirable? A "slap" mode per se? A mid boost? Once again, killer information so far everyone.
 
For the love of god, please make Left handed an option! I hate seeing those amazing basses and being unable to purchase or play because I can't play right handed.

Also humbuckers, active/passive switch. Too many basses just go for the P or P/J sets.
 
Are you going to design and/or build your preamp in house or have someone else do it? Depending on the design a series/parallel switch might be good to have. I would look at the systems built by Audere, Sadowsky, Aguilar, Fender (American Deluxe), Warwick, Carvin and the various major pickup manufacturers. There is also the Varitone (see certainbass.com) but I believe it is a passive only voicing filter. I would survey the attendees at the NAMM show, pick out the best design features from what currently exists, and figure out what you can do to make a better high quality preamp at a cost that won't drive up your instrument price too much. Sounds like this would be just an average typical day for someone like you.
 
Are you going to design and/or build your preamp in house or have someone else do it? Depending on the design a series/parallel switch might be good to have. I would look at the systems built by Audere, Sadowsky, Aguilar, Fender (American Deluxe), Warwick, Carvin and the various major pickup manufacturers. There is also the Varitone (see certainbass.com) but I believe it is a passive only voicing filter. I would survey the attendees at the NAMM show, pick out the best design features from what currently exists, and figure out what you can do to make a better high quality preamp at a cost that won't drive up your instrument price too much. Sounds like this would be just an average typical day for someone like you.

Average, typical...maybe :)

Just in a different venue. Thanks for the information. Lefties would be an option as well. Just special order for a small added fee- Nothing outrageous.