Question about Hofner Basses

[newbassdude]

I have been playing piano for about 10 years now, but when it comes to basses I am completely new. I was looking to invest some money into one of the Hofner replicas to self-teach myself the bass. I have been doing some research and reading reviews, and I'm stuck between two of them:

Hofner Icon Series Vintage Violin Bass
http://bass-guitars.musiciansfriend.com/product/Hofner-Icon-Series-Vintage-Violin-Bass?sku=511788

and

Hofner Icon B Electric Bass
Invalid Link Removed

The prices appear to be pretty close, but what is the difference between the two? Any comments would be helpful, Thanks!

 

[Johnny Alien]

I think these are the same bass.

 

[newbassdude]

Ha really? well i guess that helps thanks

 

[Johnny Alien]

The list prices are different but all the specs appear to be the same so I am going to guess there is no difference. If you pick one up make sure to post your thoughts. I just got a Contemporary Club bass that I really like alot.

 

[newbassdude]

alright, thanks. i was planning to order it today or tomorrow. i'll post how i like it when it arrives (if i remember )

 

[bassplayer8953]

Look closely...the Icon from zzounds includes a case. Usually a case goes for around 75, which is just about the difference between the 2 retailers prices.

As a former owner of a 500-1 (German) Hofner, I'd suggest you check out the contemporary series, if you can afford it. I've checked out both the imports, and the contemporary is a much closer copy of the original than the Icon. In fact, with the exception of the tone knobs, you'd be seriously challenged to tell the difference between the contemporary and the German version, looks-wise. As far as tone, well, they're short scale...and very boomy sounding...all of 'em.