• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Questions on this article about Carol Kaye

Invalid Link Removed

I read this article today about Carol Kaye by Chris Zappa. However, when I got to the list of records she is credited on in the article, a lot of early Motown songs were on the list. Wasn't James Jamerson the bassist on those tracks, maybe Bob Babbitt on a few?
 
To say who played on what gets murky.

CK herself and others around in those days explain it away that the producers or the studios who posted the credits often did not note the many times somebody else might have been asked in to re-record a part after the initial tracking, as they fine tuned or tweaked the final arrangement put on the commercial release.

I've read this enough from other players in other places besides the West Coast/Wrecking Crew days to think it's entirely possible. Nathan East tells a story of how after Motown moved to LA from Detroit, and Jamerson finally broke down and grudgingly made the move, he was going downhill from his alcohol problems and Nate had been called in to play over the stuff James laid down in a less than perfect state. He fibbed and said he was already booked, though he's sure somebody re-did that track, eventually credited to Jamerson, not accurate at all. He could not bring himself to record over Jamerson (The idea that a broken Jamerson had to buy a ticket and sit in the audience in the rafters for MOTOWN 25 is so sad).

Then there's a whole 'nother rumor of 'ghost' parts over the years where the band's bassist was too far out of it to work correctly, and after hours a session bassist would be brought in to right the parts. This is often rumored, but no one willing to talk about it in broad daylight. Heard this a lot in the 'hair metal' days.

The ultimate determination of who's on a lot of those hit records has been a subject of much back and forth between CK and others, often turning a bit ugly. Over time, we're losing all those master players from those days and who knows if it will ever be proved about this or that record.
 
This is an oft-contested topic.

For many years Kaye (an undeniably super-accomplished player with thousands of confirmed recording credits) claimed she played on hits that many felt she couldn’t possibly have played on. For a lot of people it put her claims into question and led them to believe she just played on so much stuff she couldn’t remember what.

In recent years some very careful research turned up proof that many of her claims were actually right.

Between the recordings she’s confirmed to have played on, those she believes to have played on and those the may have but nobody’s really sure, there’s a lot of messiness out there on the internet. Some of it is just going to end up remaining a mystery, I think.

Since I’m a huge fan of all the session players of that era; Kaye, Jamerson, Babbit as well as quite a few others, and since much of the record keeping of that era was incomplete, I try not to worry too much about who played on what. Those folks were often working multiple sessions per day, seven days per week. I certainly wouldn’t blame them for misremembering something.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4SG and Alkali Ike