• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Recording Tips/Advice. What am I doing wrong? What can be done better?

Yeah somewhere below the first clipping indication should give the best signal to noise ratio. But sounds like clipping to me, perhaps in a stage not covered by the indicator? Is the bass active?
 
  • Like
Reactions: LBS-bass
Digital recording is different than recording to tape. Ideally you want to record at -18db peaking around -10 to -12 db. I don't hear what you are hearing in regards to buzzing. It might your monitoring setup or the FX. Bass signal over noise does not apply in the digital recording. It does in tape though.

Nice solo BTW, I love that song.
Thank you!
This is useful information. I appreciate the kind words as well.
 
Sounds pretty good, not really noticing where it's clipping, except maybe in a couple of spots. Could it be your monitors/amp/phones clipping? The octopus shirt is a nice touch.
Thanks!
Yea, I am noticing how much it varies in sound quality simply depending on what I listen to it through (headphones, computer speakers, cell phone, etc.). It sounds brutal on my iPhone 8s, but through my laptop it sounds fine. So perhaps this is just an external thing. I just don't know enough about sound/recording to truly understand or know what I'm doing.
 
Digital recording is different than recording to tape. Ideally you want to record at -18db peaking around -10 to -12 db. I don't hear what you are hearing in regards to buzzing. It might your monitoring setup or the FX. Bass signal over noise does not apply in the digital recording. It does in tape though.

Nice solo BTW, I love that song.

+1

I don't hear any buzzing either. I do hear the odd clip at various points. Watch your input gain on the interface. You never want it in the red in the digital realm (or yellow, if you have yellow indicators).
 
Thanks!
Yea, I am noticing how much it varies in sound quality simply depending on what I listen to it through (headphones, computer speakers, cell phone, etc.). It sounds brutal on my iPhone 8s, but through my laptop it sounds fine. So perhaps this is just an external thing. I just don't know enough about sound/recording to truly understand or know what I'm doing.

Yes, this will confound you to no end! I listened to your clip through my reference monitors and my pretty decent Sennheiser HD600 headphones. Sounded pretty good overall to me.

YouTube's compression algorithms can also do a number on your finely crafted mix!
 
My guess is your DAW that is not setup well enough.

I had a lot of buzzing or intense distortion with Ableton until I removed it and removed Pro Tools fro my system and reinstall Ableton using the recommended setting. Now everything is perfect
 
Keep an eye on the output levels, too. It is easy to have things get away from you, and clip the output if you don't practice proper gain-staging. One of the other benefits of recording at around -18dBFS RMD, other than not worrying about clipping your converters, is that you have a lot more headroom to play with in the mix, too.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kevindahl
T am noticing how much it varies in sound quality simply depending on what I listen to it through (headphones, computer speakers, cell phone, etc.). It sounds brutal on my iPhone 8s, but through my laptop it sounds fine.

Pro engineers typically mix using multiple speakers to make sure the mix works on all. Typically one "flat" set that reveals all the detail. Then more colored speakers that the average listener might have.

I'm just a hobbyist, I use the following:

1. M-Audio Bx5 powered monitors
Basic "near field" (no more than 3 feet away) monitor. It's at the low end of the price scale but does the job, very crisp and the bass is tight. I do NOT use a sub, that's a recipe for totally screwing up the low end. I use these for 80% of the mixing, I come back to them if something sounds off in different speakers.

2. Kenwood 8" bookshelf speakers
Left over from a mid-70s stereo rig. These are closer to the average joe's speaker setup. By comparison with the Bx5s, more powerful but less detailed bass, less high end.

3. Sony cassette recorder
Again a 70s leftover. It's a deck built for portable recording so it has a small (4"?) monitor speaker...mono! I use this to represent a typical craptastic speaker like in a $50 boombox. This one is hard to make sound right, especially in the low end.

4. Phones
I have more headphones than I can use...long story there...but I listen over a couple different sets and also earbuds.

5. Car
Burn a CD, use a thumb drive., Bluetooth, etc. and listen in your car. If you have more than one, try them all.

6. When I'm done I listen on my stereo, strictly mid-fi hardware except for some very nice sounding Tetra speakers. Since I'm familiar with listening on that system, it's easy to tell if my mix holds up against released recordings.

Optional: Not that I need it, because I'm not releasing recordings, but today I'd probably add a small Bluetooth speaker to the list.

Listen at multiple volume levels with each set of speakers. I have a switch that lets me A-B the Bx5s, Kenwoods and Sony at the same volume. Otherwise, whatever is loudest tends to sound best. Spend a lot of time listening at low levels to make sure everything is audible and properly balanced. It's easy to make a mix sound good at deafening levels, same phenomenon as your bass amp sounding better when it's cranked than at bedroom level.

Tip: as far as distortion, asothers noted in digital you want to keep levels down to about -12 on the meters when recording each part. For bass, you then want to add compression and EQ to fine tune it. Use what's in your recording software, not pedals.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kevindahl
Digital recording is different than recording to tape. Ideally you want to record at -18db peaking around -10 to -12 db. I don't hear what you are hearing in regards to buzzing. It might your monitoring setup or the FX. Bass signal over noise does not apply in the digital recording. It does in tape though.

Nice solo BTW, I love that song.

As you said, it doesn’t matter where you record in digital, as long as you don’t clip: -18 is fine and so is -6, as long as the peaks don’t get chopped off.

Analog modeled plugins need more headroom, but you can always clip gain down after recording if need be.
Hey friends,

Just recorded this video. Sounds good at low/medium volumes, but gets that harsh hiss/buzz/clipping sound when you turn it up a bit.
How can I avoid that? Or remove it?
Not sure what I'm doing wrong.
I recorded this through a focusrite scarlett solo into garageband. No indication of clipping.


Thanks for your help!
Mike


The “clipping” you’re hearing is just your tiny cell phone speakers distorting due to excess bass frequencies: exceeding their xmax, just like how you can distort a bad cab by pushing the cab’s frequencies too heavily at too high of a volume.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kevindahl
I downloaded a copy direct from YouTube, and there is no indication of clipping, the highest peak is at -0.3 db.
The waveform looks as I would have expected from a visual stand point.
2020-05-02_094403.jpg

Mixing a loop with live playing is always very challenging.
You certainly did nothing wrong and if you are having playback issues I would suggest it's on your end.
Compression on the loop and live playing might help you get a more equal mix.

Good luck,
Dirk