• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

REDDI vs P15 Poll Time. 2017 update coming soon!

After all the clips which one?


  • Total voters
    109
That would be really, really tough to do.
image.jpeg
 
Superstacks, custom jobs... Maybe it's time for a Broughton Megathread.

Yes, we probably should have some sort of club thread in the effects section.

Once Josh comes back from vacation, the following will be on my boards:

-SuperStack
-Powerstack
-Azure Drive v2
-Broughton PLL
-Broughctave
-LHPF

Add the P-15 to that, lots of Broughton stuff :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: blindrabbit

Seeing that and the other pic you posted, it appears the MOSFET is used to control the B+ voltage. The Cinemag CM-2810 is the audio transformer for output, unlike the REDDI which is much bigger (looks more like an output transformer from a Marshall).

Looks like a simple circuit heavily based on the B15N preamp section. Exceptions appear to be the 6.3Vdc where the B15N uses 6.3Vac, SS rectifier versus the tube rectifier of the B15N, and the change to the B+ voltage.

The two yellow transformers in the back are the power transformers for the plate and filament voltage. Each appear to have a full-wave rectifier. The other black heat sink will be the voltage regulator as DC will be used on the filaments for less noise.

The resistors and caps between the tube and the front panel appear to be the tone stack.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: JFOC
The first two takes of the P bass sound pretty close, but the first one sounds a bit thicker and warmer, to my ears. The last one is a bit more clear but thinner. My guess would be the P-15 (maybe with a little more bass), Reddi, 800B. I feel like I'm wrong more often than not, though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bdowd
The first two takes of the P bass sound pretty close, but the first one sounds a bit thicker and warmer, to my ears. The last one is a bit more clear but thinner. My guess would be the P-15 (maybe with a little more bass), Reddi, 800B. I feel like I'm wrong more often than not, though.
Yeah- I was going to describe it the exact same way. So little difference (especially if a touch of EQ was added) between the first two. The third sounds thin and anemic comparatively.
 
For the P with flats it goes in this order.
1. REDDI set at 10 o'clock
2. P-15 set at 10 o'clock (Treble,bass,level)
3. JKPVSF800B set with the treble at 10 o'clock, mids at noon, bass at 1 o'clock and the level at 9 o'clock.

The Jazz with Rotos and a very small touch of my Dunwichamps Volt Thrower
1. P-15 everything at 10 o'clock
2. REDDI set at 10 o'clock.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LowEndWooly
Total lurker here... I really like the P15 and Reddi, though one more than the other.

I have a question for those of you recording on computer...

Do you run your nice, fat DI into a USB interface then into the computer? Does the quality of the interface change the end result? ( I think I may know the answer to the last one.)

OR

Am I wasting resources on a nice DI only to put it into an ART Tube MP interface before Reaper?

Thanks for the clips!