• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Removing the pickguard for more tone?

joelb79 said:
I was talking with the bass play from rare earth the other day after an open mic jam, and he told me that he removes the pick guard from all of his basses now, due to the fact that the pickguard eats some of the tone up.

has anybody tried this and can confirm? I would love to think that my musicman would sound any better without the pick guard, but i dont think it will look any better.


Hmmm:hmm: ....it wasn't posted on April 1st.............hmmm:hmm: .......fine....if NO ONE here will ask......whimps:rollno:......
ARE YOU SERIOUS??!?!?!?!?
I mean, serioulsy.....ARE YOU SERIOUS?!?!?! He actually SAID this?? I mean to you??? And you heard him correct right??

Well, please tell me you just smiled and nodded. Calmly excused yourself and walked away giggling.

Tell this guy to have another drink, because I sure remember when I had my first one!! I said all kind of crazy a$$ $hit too!!

See now boys and girls, this is what happens when you either drink too much or do too many drugs. You say crazy crazy stuff like "I remove the pickguard because it eats up tone".

Just when I think I've heard it all.......:rollno:
 
Crap!!!
Joel!!!
I didn't put two and two together man!!!! I know who you are (kinda;) )

Dude, who is this guy?????

And please tell me your kidding about the pickguard on your MM.
After 20+ years and countless basses with pickguards on and off.......aww nevermind.

Who is this guy????
If you don't want to "out" him here, PM me.

Is it Randy Burgdoff??? He's the current guy. And there are pictures of him with a pickguard on his P-Bass on their web site!!
 
This is almost as funny as the thread about "vintige air" in old sealed cabs in the amp section.

Someone wondered if removing drivers to allow fresh air to circulate would improve the tone of an old sealed vintage cab. Others quickly decided that vintage air had mojo and that they might try to bottle and sell vintage air from their old cabs on ebay. Others still pondered if using vintage fans to blow air into the driver holes of modern sealed cabs would re-create the tone effects of vintage air (If you think about it... there was less pollution in the air back then).

And then there was the ebay auction for about three inches of green pre-CBS wire. The true mojo of a bass comes from old $h1tty wire.:p
 
MikeBass said:
Crap!!!
Joel!!!
I didn't put two and two together man!!!! I know who you are (kinda;) )

Dude, who is this guy?????

And please tell me your kidding about the pickguard on your MM.
After 20+ years and countless basses with pickguards on and off.......aww nevermind.

Who is this guy????
If you don't want to "out" him here, PM me.

Is it Randy Burgdoff??? He's the current guy. And there are pictures of him with a pickguard on his P-Bass on their web site!!

yeah thats him. Bird, as everybody calls him.



OkOKOKOkOkOkOkOKKO!!! ENOUGH WITH THE JOKES! I cant stop laughing and i need some sleep.

did it sound better? : if it did, it was almost noticable. I think more or less, the 3mm thick pickguard gave me less space to rest my thumb on the bass, so i was probably more agressive in my fingerstyle, giving me a 'better' tone for some songs.

But in all honesty, when i grabbed a pick for some van morrison, no difference. so... the jokes are right.

but my bass looks like ****. so on it goes again.


But now i have a dilemma.. how do i get the pixie dust back on my bass. and how do i get my bass back on the pickguard. and who knows a good loanshark for the $10,000 pickguard?!:crying:
 
Serious Question:

I have an SX 75 model in sunburst and I removed the pick guard. Disappointed.


I was hoping to find something like this:
Invalid Link Removed

But instead, the neck pick up is centered in a huge cavity that encircles the p-up like a moat.

Should I:

A) Get another Ash body
B) Fill the huge neck p-up cavity with a soapbar bart?
c) Fill the space with a wood replacement


Help!

SX bass: (but with black pick guard)
[Invalid or Expired Link Removed]