• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Double Bass Replacing AMT S25B - Xlson or Neumann MCM114

After 16 years with my AMT S25B, it looks like it’s finally time to move on. There’s some audible rattling I can’t quite track down, and the gooseneck isn’t nearly as stable as it used to be. And well… as I’ve read some of us know how AMT customer service can be. So maybe it’s just a good excuse to try something new.

I was close to pulling the trigger on a Neumann, but then I came across Xlson and that definitely got my attention. Part of me wants to go with the Xlson because I like supporting smaller companies that make interesting gear. On the other hand, the Neumann seems like the simpler option — straight into the Felix, no extra box or power supply needed.

My typical setup is sometimes mic straight to FOH + Lifeline into an amp, and sometimes mic blended with a Lifeline through a Grace Felix into my amp. I almost always play with a drummer, so stage volume is definitely a factor. Since the Lifeline already covers the low end pretty well, I usually point the mic toward the fingerboard or the bridge to capture more of the natural string sound and finger attack.

Also worth mentioning: my bass is about a 130-year-old Austrian flatback. It has a lot of character, but like many older instruments it can occasionally develop a little buzz or rattle somewhere if the wood dries out (I’m trying my best to prevent it). For those who’ve used Xlson or Neumann - is either mic more prone to picking up these mechanical noises on older flatbacks?

Has anyone here compared the two in a live setting? If you’ve used either with a Lifeline or a Felix, I’d really love to hear your experience. And I’d be very interested in hearing how it’s working for you on gigs.
 
Not sure if you know, but Ron Oswanski (previously AMT sales, artist relations, and design) has started his own company. Might be a useful resource: High-Quality Instrument Microphones
I’m aware of that, but once you factor in taxes, customs, and shipping from the US to Europe, an Evno mic ends up costing way more than a Neumann or Xlson, so yeah… that’s just not for me.
 
I have no “old flat back”, but I use the Neumann with an Felix on my “new” flat back, the Primus..;) and I like it very much..The Neumann replaced the Remix because of its easier handling and more flexible sound options… you have a lot more possibilities to “equalize” the sound by changing positions and by changing the capsule..soundwise for my ears it’s near by my Schoeps Mk5 and without knowing the Xlson I find it hard to imagine the Xlson to sound “better”…:P;) In “louder environments” I use to combine the Neumann with an Ehrlund PU, which also works really fine..:)
In summary for me the Neumann MCM system seems to be the “actual state-of-the-art”-solution for live setups…:)
 
The best microphones for DB I’ve used on my bass and own are the Remic’s. Peter loaned a group of TB members the one of the original “Chuck Israels” Xlsons for a trial. On my sloping flatback bass it was difficult to get it to stay in a position where I could maintain a decent sound. That’s why I went with a pair of Remic’s. (One slightly used Remic Red and a brand new Remic Green) They’re easy to mount, sound great and are relatively feedback resistant. Just my take.
 
My hesitation solved itself in a usual way - I found new Neumann for a really good price. I hope I’ll got to try it this week on very small stage or if the delivery will be late - next week on medium stage.
Thanks for all the replies!
I think you will love it. Did you get the side clip? I think that is the most versatile and will be familiar to you if you know the AMT. Neumann’s clamp is so well designed. Very easy to use.