Yes ANOTHER pickup comparison thread haha but I don't think this one has been done (at least I couldn't find one). Im looking to upgrade my MIM Fender P-Bass, I prefer the late 50s split coil P-Bass sound than the 60s. But I would like them to be a bit louder with some more "clang" as it were. I have been debating on getting a SD SPB-1, but I find its just a little too quiet and polite for my tastes. I like the SPB-4 because it has that "clang" and "punch" without losing much clarity or distorting under 100% volume. The few clips Ive heard and reviews Ive read of the P-46 seem that it has excellent clarity and has that extra "clang and punch", but my concern is that it'll be TOO clear and hi-fi sounding. Ive read LOTS of people swear by them, that they are the one of the best P-Bass pickups out there. Both pickups are close to the same price which is why its a toss up. Also I have considered the EMG GZR, but ultimately I don't think its for me. Pickups I also liked are the Fender Pure Vintage 58 and the Seymour Duncan Antiquity I, but as they are out of production its a bit harder to find and more expensive. What do you guys think? P.S Not really looking for other suggestions unless its within the same price range.