• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Searching a snappy, modern Pbass

Maple fretboard, steel round wounds make a big difference for me in different P basses.

Can you give a recorded example of a tone that you are looking for? Sometimes it's a different pickup configuration as others have suggested.
 
Would any of the various active P-Bass options available fit the bill, or adding active electronics to an existing P?

I generally think of active basses as having a tighter, more direct, more modern sound. Paired with some steel rounds, one would expect more upper mid content.

For me I like the sound you're describing as far as I can surmise, and I find that an amp with parametric EQ helps direct the mid bump, or pedals like the MXR 6-band and 10-band EQs may be options that would be easy and inexpensive to try out.
I think the EMG active P pickup is quite snappy. Its solderless connection allows for easy installation. Though my experience is with the HB model, which is the P in a guitar humbucker housing. They also make it in soapbar housing (35P, 40P).
 
Sandberg. Even the "low" line (still outstanding quality) Electra series VS4. Looks like a nice P Bass. Feels like one too. Tonally, it's a completely different animal. Much more modern sounding than any Fender I've ever heard.
I came here to write this. I've owned 4 Sandbergs and recently sold a VS4 Active that would have fit your needs probably. Another tip is to use a pick if you want bright and articulate.
 
I've been experimenting with pickups in both my main P basses. I play in a Fleetwood tribute and didn't want anything snappy or bright sounding I settled on Dimarzio model P pups, lots of low mid with less sizzle then stock P pups. I've tried the EMG Gzr and other OE 60's replacements but just too bright for my needs, almost a single coil vibe compared to the Model P's… However, that might be the direction you want to go.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Artman and Iristone
You might like the Schecter CV4 It covers a large tonal territory, has a 3 way switch for pickup selection and a 3-way series/split/parallel switches for each pickup.

1724866697111.jpeg
 
Lightweight? P/J pickup config? Snappy tone?

Thought about an Ibanez P/J model? New or Used, they do/did a lot more than just the Bartolini soapbars. You can throw DiMarzios in there too (what I did) and run it passive, or an Audere like mine have. Light, flexible, and very present tone. Just my $0.02 :cool:
 
Snappy? I assume you might mean hi-fi, modern. Active basses will sound sparkly on top and have deep lows.

There are too many options to list but Stingray or Active Jazz will get you there immediately. If money is a consideration, look at a "Sterling By MusicMan Stingray" or a Mexican Active JBass Plus. A lot of bass guitar for the money.

If you add a more modern sounding bass to your collection, keep your PBass. You will always appreciate having that sound in your collection.

I have a very large collection of basses, two that are extremely "snappy'" sounding basses are my Spector and my Dingwall.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Artman
Sandberg
Jazz bass (Fender or Sadowsky or Lull or the various japanese makes)
Spector NS2
A fender P with a gloss maple neck, active pickup (or similarly voiced passive)

Bright roundwounds.

Steels if you dont mind the feel
Various nickels have very bright characteristics.
 

$49.95
They do have P basses also but 3k+

If you want P bass style[not any other style Jazz etc.] in your price range with a 'Modern' P tone may be difficult; even in used market most manufactures usually stress 'Vintage'

Sadowsky Metroexpress seems a good value BUT it is shaped like a Jazz

I would go listen to Fender Pro or Fender Player Deluxe active/passive
 
Last edited:
Try a PJ out but don't run the p and j pups in parallel, run them in series instead. Parallel tends to get very mid scoopy, but series shifts the mid peak up a little, adds more bottom, more top and it still sounds like a P bass. It is a snappy p bass sound IMO.
I have Dimarzio Split P and Ultra Jazz in my bass.



This is how I wired it. Bass is either P pup solo or P and J in series. I decided not to add a tone pot and just opted for a switch because I personally either run full tone or full treble dump.
IMG_0120.jpeg
Here is a quick bass demo I slapped together after I finished the bass a few weeks ago. Not using a pick on the 3rd bass loop just a bit of my finger nails when finger picking.
 
Last edited: