• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Sell me on a US-made Stingray

Should I...

  • Stick with the Sterling SUB, don't be a fool, it does what you want, and you know you love a deal

    Votes: 54 32.9%
  • Get a EBMM Classic StingRay, it's worth the 8x price difference because... (comment please)

    Votes: 37 22.6%
  • Get some other EBMM model (specify in comments)

    Votes: 27 16.5%
  • Carrots

    Votes: 46 28.0%

  • Total voters
    164
First stingray I bought cost $465. Bought several others for under 800. Bought a used sterling for 650 once. USA subs, several under $200 and others for $450. All of these were found on cl. I have owned many SBMM, they are nice and sound like a ray but a real one always feels and sound better. IMHO
 
I also have a sub Ray 4. I also had a ray34 but didn't like the wider neck, something to keep in mind. us Ray's have a wider neck more like a precision. the sub has a jazz like neck (38mm nut) otherwise you could look at the Sterling by ebmm. my sub is one of the older made in Indonesia, I traded for it (used) and I think the preamp was replaced. it was trash so I removed it. the stock pickup would be ok if it weren't hardwired in series which makes it muddy. I replaced with a good one and replaced the pots with two switches for parallel/series north coil South coil. there's actually a big difference between the coils soloed. it sounds killer now. you should keep it and upgrade the electronics imo. I also plan on getting a better looking bridge like the real deal and refinishing it in oil
 
If you truly love the tone and feel of your SUB, no reason to get a classic or newer model. I think they do sound different, and I can just feel the quality difference in my hands, but you said you got the tone you were looking for... so might as well save the cash! If you want an in-between upgrade, the Sterling 34 is an excellent bass. I loved mine, was just too heavy for me. Personally, I'm saving for a Stingray Special– that's my long-term goal.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pings Bass
Why not join a band?
I would LOVE to. I have zero available time. Overly taxing job, lots of business travel, three kids ages 7 and under, large home and property to care for, the list goes on.
that string height.... that's not actually the real playable action on that bass!?!?! the E string is unplayable that low!? it looks like they're all against the frets except the g has a tiny spec of space under it that might make that one string playable with a very light action.

Besides that.... omg that is a gorgeous fretboard.
Might be a function of the camera angle, or else the wall hanger is pressing on the strings.
Or maybe the fret wrap was on there when I took the photo, not sure.
But yeah, that fretboard is 2 die 4! :-)

Here it is in action:
 
Yeah, but regardless of quality, features, budget, or anything else, the overarching rule of thumb on TB is that the number of basses you need is always N+1 where N is the number of basses that you currently own.
That is why 1.5 years ago before I was active on TB, I had 13 basses that I had accumulated over almost 40 years of playing bass, and now after 1.5 years of being active on TB, I have about 80 basses, and a wife that is threatening divorce over it. If I sold all my basses today, I could literally pay off my mortgage tomorrow, almost exactly to the dollar. And I only actually ever play maybe 6 or 8 of them, mostly only the same 2 or 3. And I only play at home, with headphones, unless nobody else is at home. Not even in a band or anything. How pathetic is that?

But I will tell you what - this BFR StingRay with a roasted neck is one of the absolutely best playing and sounding 4-strings I have encountered in my life. And that's putting it up against Foderas, MTDs, Sadowskys, LeFays, Marleauxs, Skjolds, and any other top tier bass you could name. (I have all of those.) Too bad you aren't nearby, I'd invite you to check it out in person and see for yourself. Of course, if you played it, it would be keeping you up at night every night until you bought it.
View attachment 3404262

My friend, when you say 80 basses, do you mean there is a place in your residence with 80 basses hanging out right now? Do you have a storage unit somewhere? What are the logistics of owning 80 instruments? Have you posted a picture of the whole stable?

To be fair, that’s awesome as hell (other than the marital-argument aspect). Sorry for getting off topic.

Back on topic... that Ball Family Reserve looks great. I’ve played some absolutely fantastic ones. They’re the real deal.
 
I'm not going to help you here: go find a used one in a color you like and just do it. (And factor in the cost to go get the frets touched up by a pro, if they're worn.) Save the box, and you can sell it if you're underwhelmed after a month.

I have basses at every levels of build from beater to coffee-table. All have had the electronics tweaked until they're suitable for any occasion; each plays well enough that I could sell all the rest and be just fine, if a bit bored. And as I talk I find myself intellectually convincing myself that there's really not much difference. But when I'm holding one and playing, the nicer basses..are simply nicer. Sure, there's a bit of a "diminishing returns" effect past the $1500 range, and there's plenty of snake oil if you're not careful, but nicer basses are nicer. There, I've said it.

Now if you'll excuse me, I have to go apologize to my OLP.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pings Bass
My friend, when you say 80 basses, do you mean there is a place in your residence with 80 basses hanging out right now? Do you have a storage unit somewhere? What are the logistics of owning 80 instruments? Have you posted a picture of the whole stable?

To be fair, that’s awesome as hell (other than the marital-argument aspect). Sorry for getting off topic.

Back on topic... that Ball Family Reserve looks great. I’ve played some absolutely fantastic ones. They’re the real deal.
The main logistics are:
a) My kids don't have a playroom, which is unfortunate.
b) It was totally worth it to invest $3,000 in climate control equipment so that I never have to touch a truss rod or even tune anything.
c) I play so little that I barely ever have to change any strings, but I have 75 sets of new strings in a box for when/if I do need to change any strings.
d) I hardly get any sleep because on the rare occasions (always late night) when I don't have to be either working or spending time with the family or doing home maintenance jobs, I stay up all night playing along with a Beat Buddy and making up bass grooves. The lack of sleep impairs my judgment, and in those weak and impaired moments, I click on the TalkBass Classifieds and buy more basses.
 
The main logistics are:
a) My kids don't have a playroom, which is unfortunate.
b) It was totally worth it to invest $3,000 in climate control equipment so that I never have to touch a truss rod or even tune anything.
c) I play so little that I barely ever have to change any strings, but I have 75 sets of new strings in a box for when/if I do need to change any strings.
d) I hardly get any sleep because on the rare occasions (always late night) when I don't have to be either working or spending time with the family or doing home maintenance jobs, I stay up all night playing along with a Beat Buddy and making up bass grooves. The lack of sleep impairs my judgment, and in those weak and impaired moments, I click on the TalkBass Classifieds and buy more basses.

I want pictures of the 80 basses
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pings Bass
I want pictures of the 80 basses
It's not practical to fit them all in a single photo. I don't have time to move them all to do that.
Here are some of them.
 

Attachments

  • 20190502_173656.jpg
    20190502_173656.jpg
    694.6 KB · Views: 21
  • 20180911_233157.jpg
    20180911_233157.jpg
    913.6 KB · Views: 20
Enjoy your Sub, maybe upgrade electronics if you hear something you like on YouTube.

Try fret leveling and dressing to keep your playability in the zone you like.

Maybe you are an HH, HS, etc guy. Cut those into your Sub. You decide you are a Classic guy, then cut in a 5string pickup. Live with it for a while to see if it's a lifelong thing, or a fling.

Once you've used that Sub in like a pair of broken in work boots go compare the Special for it's different construction methodology. Roasted neck, lighter body, etc is different. Your Sub is built along the lines of the various Stingray iterations up to the Special.

Decide what works best for you and buy the 2nd MM. Worst comes to worst you built out some custom config and you'll Custom Shop a Stingray for yourself to spec.
 
My Stingray Special 4HH is the finest instrument I have ever played or owned. It let me sell all my other basses. It's that good.

Yeah man, how many guys have I seen that figured out HH was their thing after years of regular Ray's or Sterling's blows my mind.

Just pull one down and play it for a while.

I bought my 77 P in the 80s. It hangs on the wall and only gets played on the rare occasion when I need a weak signal, dull, thumpy tone, mediocre action and pedestrian appearance. :p

You nailed it, the traditional P guys think they're swinging Thor's hammer or something.

They've missed out on anything modern MM or dual coil humbucker equipped somehow.

Want an answer to why there aren't many 5string Ps, well it's bc SR5, $$5, SR5 HH, etc.
 
The main logistics are:
a) My kids don't have a playroom, which is unfortunate.
b) It was totally worth it to invest $3,000 in climate control equipment so that I never have to touch a truss rod or even tune anything.
c) I play so little that I barely ever have to change any strings, but I have 75 sets of new strings in a box for when/if I do need to change any strings.
d) I hardly get any sleep because on the rare occasions (always late night) when I don't have to be either working or spending time with the family or doing home maintenance jobs, I stay up all night playing along with a Beat Buddy and making up bass grooves. The lack of sleep impairs my judgment, and in those weak and impaired moments, I click on the TalkBass Classifieds and buy more basses.

Thanks for taking the time to reply.

Sorry, I’ll try to stay on topic! The other thing that EBMM USA offers is those delicious looking roasted maple necks. Dear lord do they look great. However silly it may be, basses that look better are more fun to play, aren’t they?
 
  • Like
Reactions: JoshS and Jimruth
You nailed it, the traditional P guys think they're swinging Thor's hammer or something.

They've missed out on anything modern MM or dual coil humbucker equipped somehow.

I mean, I get that if you're playing oldies rock, you want that "P bass with flats" tone, maybe even with string mutes. And I think TB def skews toward boomers playing oldies rock (not that there's anything wrong with that). But I spent years on that thing trying to coax a modern tone out of it (bright strings, bi-amped rig, etc). Got closer with a Jazz Bass Special with active P/Js, but realized some time in the 90s I needed humbuckers and a pre-amp to really nail the tone I was chasing.

Anyway, if somebody wants me to record a dull and indistinct thumping sound behind their rock guitars, I've got just the thing hanging on my wall. The dead Rotosound 66s on it sound about like flats. Or I could just knock on the side of an old cardboard box full of jello.

I fully appreciate that the 2nd gen P-Bass is a classic design, I really do, or I wouldn't have kept mine. But come on, St. Leo had several significant iterations and improvements on the bass guitar after 1957.