• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Selling a busted combo. What's reasonable?

Mar 31, 2011
1,254
158
First up. This is not a PC thread. I am not a supporting member so this isn't me looking for a PC.

I was going through the shed looking for clutter to sell and I came across my old Laney HCM65B which I had when I was first playing out with people at uni.

I replaced the amp because I stuffed it up somehow. I don't know why but it's got a high end choked out crackle coming through the speaker and it's essentially unusable.

Here's a few facts to start off with:
1. This is one thing among about a dozen items I have to sell. I'm time poor and cannot be bothered diagnosing the problem.
2. I'm not able to repair the amp, nor do I have an inclination to try to do so.

Now bearing in mind that second hand I don't think a working HCM65B would fetch me much anyway, I just need to get rid of the damn thing. The catch is that I just simply don't want to give it away because at the end of the day it's a good enclosure and I'm suspicious that there's probably not a lot wrong with it. It will probably take some cluey amp cat about half an hour to fix it. But obviously me taking it to a tech would be overcapitalising because it would cost me more than I could sell it for.

So here's the question. I'm clearly going to outline the problem while trying to sell it. Would a starting price of 60% of what a working 2nd hand unit would go for be a bad place to start? If not, what would be your expectation of a starting price?

I once sold my burnt out Behringer head for $140 so I know people are out there who are keen to recondition almost anything but I really need to not waste time highballing and I also never want to hamstring myself and give someone else a total steal.
 
Sounds like you fried the speaker. The amp portion may be fine. So doesn't sound far out of line as replacing the speaker is easy.

Hmmmmm.......I kinda doubt it? It's typically hard to kill the speaker in a combo simply because it's designed to be impossible to overpower it. Could possibly happen, but my money's on a bad solder joint, probably one of the control pots. Been there, but not with this particular unit. Easy fix if I'm right.
Or it could be the famous 'dirty effects loop jack' problem? I just fixed a Phil Jones Briefcase with that issue.

In any case, if the OP just wants to dump it my guess is 50% of market value of a working unit would be about right (but first I'd run a cable into/out of the effects loop jacks a few times for giggles) ;)
 
It was never a very good unit and I did bully it without remorse. Being a kid is expensive. I also suspected the speaker back when it happened but my opinion is certainly inexpert.

If I can be bothered I might have a fiddle with it while I'm taking photos for Gumtree but nothing that involves a screwdriver. I've simply got better things to do. It's a cop out but that's a reality.
I'm not even sure it has an effects loop. It's in the boot of my car getting dirtier so I'll check it out when I get home from the office.
 
Hmmmmm.......I kinda doubt it? It's typically hard to kill the speaker in a combo simply because it's designed to be impossible to overpower it. Could possibly happen, but my money's on a bad solder joint, probably one of the control pots. Been there, but not with this particular unit. Easy fix if I'm right.
Or it could be the famous 'dirty effects loop jack' problem? I just fixed a Phil Jones Briefcase with that issue.

In any case, if the OP just wants to dump it my guess is 50% of market value of a working unit would be about right (but first I'd run a cable into/out of the effects loop jacks a few times for giggles) ;)

Maybe he underpowered it.
 
Put it on ebay for what you think is a reasonable amount, explain what you think has gone wrong & let the bidding war sort it out for you.

See this is my other option. Start it at nothing and see what happens. This is the direction I'm leaning. If it goes for $0.99c well sometimes life hands you lemons.
 
See this is my other option. Start it at nothing and see what happens. This is the direction I'm leaning. If it goes for $0.99c well sometimes life hands you lemons.

Theres always the "reserve" price option. Just put a reserve price of ~50% of the value of a used, working HCM65B. You can reject any stupid lowball bids. the downside of that is, ebay charges a fee for reserve price auctions. But its better than giving it away.
 
Plot twist. A few posters convinced me that it might be worth getting the amp out of the car to take a look at it so I did. I haven't plugged into this amp since I was 20 so it's been sitting under a tarp in my shed for nearly 6 years.

But for some reason it's doing a very good impression of being in perfect working order. Now, admittedly I can't really put it through its paces because I live in an apartment and despite sounding like it's made of cardboard the damn thing is actually pretty loud and I can't hear a problem anymore.

So what do I do? The high pitched niggle that I heard back in the day isn't there, at least it hasn't reared it's head in the 5 minutes I've been testing the unit. The bloody thing is either miraculously healed or it's playing possum. I still need to sell it but now what can I say?

'Sorry. This amp might or might not be a bit broken. I just don't know'

Thoroughly annoyed now. A dishonest person would just sell it for full S/H price and hope that the problem doesn't eventuate until later. An honest approach could have be sell off a perfectly working amp for a reduced guilt price! Since I'd only be prepared to be truthful I'm going to take a decent price hit. Wish I'd never fired it up because at least then I wouldn't have known.
 
Still. I'd rather get $80 than $35. I think at this stage I'll just ebay it as "May have an intermittent fault" and indicate that it should go to someone handy who can fix amps.

Problem number one is that no savvy combo appreciator is going to want a Laney Hardcore. I had a bit of a groove with it tonight and it sounds like it's made of wet paper towels.