• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Short Scale Thoughts: G&L Fallout or Squier Classic Vibe Mustang?

IMO the CV Mustang is a better looker, but the Fallout probably sounds better, is more versatile, and is likely a better instrument all around in terms of parts, materials and QC. I've had my eye on the Mustang for a while; really wanted to get a 70s walnut with maple neck to match my P, but they're rare and unreasonably expensive for something that would just check a box for me (as opposed to being a main player).
 
I own a CLF L1000 as well as an L2000. I opted for a Sterling Stingray Short Scale because I figured I had the MFD sound covered. I love how the Sterling looks, feels and plays. On top of that it sounds great.

I would check out the Sterling before you commit to the Fallout. But, I have to add that if I didn't have the L1000 I probably would have grabbed both the Stingray and the Fallout. Both would be less than my CLF L1000.

Now what was the other bass you were thinking about???
 
Last edited:
I own a CLF L1000 as well as an L2000. I opted for a Sterling Stingray Short Scale because I figured I had the MFD sound covered. I love how the Sterling looks, feels and plays. On top of that it sounds great.

I would check out the Sterling before you commit to the Fallout. But, I have to add that if I didn't have the L1000 I probably would have grabbed both the Stingray and the Fallout. Both would be less than my CLF L1000.

Now what was the other bass you were thinking about???
I concur with the SBMM shortscale, I have one and it's a beast. I might get a Fallout if my injuries don't get better, me and slab bodies don't get along any more
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mike Patton
Speaking of weight, the Fallout seems to be heavy for a short scale bass. My L1000 weighs just over 8 lbs. and CB my Stingray is 7 lbs. 5 oz. but most of the Tribute Fallouts are 9 lbs. or more. That's what my L2000 weighs!
I saw that, not sure why they'd be so heavy. My other short scales are two pounds lighter. Most of my full scale are lighter. I'd be inclined to get a L1000
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mike Patton
I'm new to the world of short-scale Bass guitars. I've tried a 32" Jaguar but am thinking of going for a 30" due to my physical limitations. I've noticed the G&L Fallout Tribute and the 60's Squier Classic Vibe Mustang "seem" to be identical in body size and shape. If you've had experience with each can you comment on if this is accurate or not? Sadly, finding these models in a store to compare has proven to be impossible (maybe due to Covid's impact on storefront retailers?). To my, admittedly, limited knowledge it looks like the G&L is possibly a more refined version - certainly the Bridge seems far beefier. Thanks in advance!View attachment 4085637 View attachment 4085636

Tried both and own the Fender Mustang PJ which (I think) is v similar to the Squier Mustang in terms of body shape. Anything G&L is going to be a serious contender IME. I found the Fallout a little more awkward than the Mustang (can't quite put my finger on why I felt that, the Mustang just gelled with me more) but it's still a good option with excellent parts and QC. I would say though that if you're looking for good SS options in that price range, also check out the Sire short scale as well (I really liked it) and also the Gretsch Junior Jet is a lot of bass for the money, sounds good and one of the lightest basses I've ever played. Separate point... retailer inventory of a lot of brands seems to be low everywhere right now. There was a lot of supply chain disruption this year because of Covid and the effects are still working their way through the chain as far as I can see. Should improve over the next few months though (hopefully.....).
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mike Patton
I'm new to the world of short-scale Bass guitars. I've tried a 32" Jaguar but am thinking of going for a 30" due to my physical limitations. I've noticed the G&L Fallout Tribute and the 60's Squier Classic Vibe Mustang "seem" to be identical in body size and shape. If you've had experience with each can you comment on if this is accurate or not? Sadly, finding these models in a store to compare has proven to be impossible (maybe due to Covid's impact on storefront retailers?). To my, admittedly, limited knowledge it looks like the G&L is possibly a more refined version - certainly the Bridge seems far beefier. Thanks in advance!View attachment 4085637 View attachment 4085636
Both.
 
I got the Mustang pictured, I really like it, as far as quality there isn't really much to comment on, it's a really nice bass. Sounds like a Mustang should! I had leftover Grover tuners I bought for nothing years ago that we're drop ins on it, if I didn't have a set laying around unused I wouldn't have changed the tuners out. A Mustang is a Mustang, it's a small P Bass!
My only suggestion is you should get a white one and we can swap pick gaurds! :thumbsup:
As for the Fallout, I haven't gotten a chance to play one but as hard as G&L Tributes go, in general they are very nice instruments that are pretty hard to beat. I had an L2000 and currently have an Asat Special guitar and they were/are great!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mike Patton
Having owned a Squier Mustang and various G&L`s over the years, I would go for the Fallout. The Mustang can be a bit dodgy qc wise whereas all the Tribute models I have owned have been excellent. Also, the Fallout is a lot more versatile due to the pickup switching options.

Have a look at Lobsters review, this may help you decide.


Thanks - my YouTube search didn't show me this.
 
Arm Cut? Great! That's one of the reasons I "physically" preferred playing Strats instead of Tele or LP. Thanks for pointing that out.

I also prefer Strat body style, so I would choose Fallout. I tried many Mustangs in local shops and never found them comfortable. I found that my Squier VM Jaguar short scale is the best combo to my Strat. You cloud look for a used one, cause they are not manufactured anymore. Wish you luck in your search!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mike Patton
I also prefer Strat body style, so I would choose Fallout. I tried many Mustangs in local shops and never found them comfortable. I found that my Squier VM Jaguar short scale is the best combo to my Strat. You cloud look for a used one, cause they are not manufactured anymore. Wish you luck in your search!
I've tried the 32" and it's a bit much for my physical limitations. I've seen a couple of 30" on Reverb - but hesitate to buy something without an easy and affordable return policy - which is rarely the case in a private party sale.
Thanks for the suggestion!
 
I own a Tribute Fallout. I had a MIJ Mustang too. After the Fallout arrived, I sold the Mustang. Case Closed.

IMG_2922.jpeg