Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Short Scale thougths
- Thread starter DrBnz
- Start date
It is chunky from front to back, it feels thicker than my Am Pro II P-Bass. I can't find the exact measurements, but in the JMJ thread on his forum there is quite a bit of info on the neck. This post and the few after it get into this. JMJ Signature Road Worn Mustang!
LOL… that is what I’ve noticed about most short scales, usually the most you’ll get is 19, 20 or (rarely) 21 frets.
I’m really liking the look of this one with the black hardware… and if pickups are easily changed could be pretty fun.
I played one of these in a music store, and really liked it. If the Gretsch G2220 didn’t exist, I think the Sire U5 would be my short scale. The neck is slightly chunkier than the Gretsch.
I have around eight short scales now , it was a Dano Longhorn that first got me . My favourite might be the Gibson DC Jr , but there are a ton of options , at most price points . I tend to pass on Fender shaped things now despite being an old Pbass guy .
JeezyMcNuggles
Inactive
- Feb 23, 2018
- 14,723
- 20,970
- Disclosures
- I suck, but nobody really notices
Get the mini Squier Jaguar with the humbucker in the sweet spot. It's pretty awesome.
You can buy a Harley Benton short scale P-bass for $88.00 online , really nice bass. On the other end is the Fender Mustang line $750-$1300 . I just recently started playing short scales exclusively , the Fender JMJ Mustang and a Harley Benton and both are fantastic .
If you like P's, then a Mustang seems like a good choice. Only the pricey American ones come with Rosewood, however.
How bout this as an alternative: G&L Tribute Fallout Short Scale Bass Guitar - Olympic White
For a little more than the G&L, but still less than the American Fender, Reverend has you covered with the Sentinel, Dub King, and Wattplower - all of which are basically kickass short P's of various flavor.
How bout this as an alternative: G&L Tribute Fallout Short Scale Bass Guitar - Olympic White
For a little more than the G&L, but still less than the American Fender, Reverend has you covered with the Sentinel, Dub King, and Wattplower - all of which are basically kickass short P's of various flavor.
Last edited:
Short scale with chunky neck....G&L Tribute Fallout
+1 here. I’ve owned MANY SS basses, high end and dirt cheap, and this made me sell my other expensive ones. It’s a great bass. The profile does in fact seem to be thicker, by the way. JMJ all day!
Thanks. I scored a Mustang in a trade, but it was heavy 8.8lb & super thin neck. I’ll look into one of these.
I am not exactly a Stingray expert so I can't really answer that question honestly. The people who know Stingrays say it is though. Some members on here that are very well respected certainly say so, so I think the answer is yes. This bass is by far the best bass I have ever owned, including my EBMM 20th anniversary 4H bass. It is super lightweight and well-balanced and sounds great. Well thought out all over, little details like the tuners being in closer to the headstock to make the bass just that much smaller. The passive boost and true single coil are amazing. Can't say enough good about this bass (except I will probably put some sort neck pickup in there some day, maybe not though, it sounds that good)
I had TI's on it until about an hour ago and it may have been the greatest tone I have ever had from my basses. I was missing that roundwound sparkle and beauty though so am trying some GHS Balanced Nickels. The TI's may end up going back on though because they just sounded that good. Or they may go on short scale Jag P/J. Who knows?
Also is there such a thing as an "old school passive Stingray"? I thought until recently there were pretty much all active. BTW I am with you on the passive thing. My last "Stingray" was active/passive and it spent the vast majority of its time in passive mode.
Anyways, if you can get one go for it. Since they are rare chances are you can sell it for whatever you paid if you buy used.
For sure not my best sounding P bass, still has the stock pickups. Although I recently discovered it actually sounds way way better with the P pickup rolled off a bit and just raising the volume downstream somewhere. Way more P bassy like that. I don't know if I will ever run that bass again with the volume all the way up.
My Hofners and Epiphone Viola have 22 frets. My Danelectro Longhorn and Silvertone 1444 have 24.
Personally I do not feel or hear any difference between Rosewood and Pau Ferro fingerboards. You can get Mexican Player Mustangs with Pau Ferro.
Rosewood isn't some kind of magical wood, it's just been extremely common in musical instruments for the last century (until CITES temporarily put a screeching halt to a lot of it!). Most of the lighter-colored 'rosewood-substitutes' will turn quite a bit darker after they have been oiled a couple times with some suitable fretboard conditioner...
I love short scales, and have moved to them exclusively now. I played the mini-P and it felt small and cheap, like a kids bass. Others don't feel that way about them - but I do. YMMV.
The Mustang PJ (Mexico) is a good choice for someone that favors P basses. They look good, they sound good, they're not too expensive, and the quality is good. I've owned a couple of them and they were both good. A few comments on them though:
(1) For me, the J pickup was useless. I never used it.
(2) People complain that the pickup selector toggle switch is bad. I had one that was janky, but I just opened it up and sprayed contact cleaner on it, and it worked great thereafter.
(3) Fender does not seem to be doing good factory setups on the ones I've owned and played in stores. Be prepared to set it up to your liking (of course this more or less applies to all basses). I will say that they setup nicely and hold setup well. No issues.
