• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

So what is next? (music)

indie is a broad genre of non-mainstream somewhat experimental music. It can be acoustic or rock or electro (to an extent).
If by "somewhat experimental" you mean "boring, sentimental to the point of being sappy and extremely difficult to enjoy" I'll agree with you. None of that stuff is really my cup of tea...

I should know, I'm from Toronto... indie is basically all that the majority of people my own age listen to around here. Especially considering that this city's demographic of twenty-somethings is primarily comprised of pretentious University students...

The future of music, I think, will be better off without major labels churning out twenty versions of the same band, regardless of the genre.
 
I think to push things forward, what about a "boy band", 5 guys, they can all sing really well, 4 of them play ukeleles and they're REALLY good...uke solo's out the ying-yang, the 5th guy plays a Jackson with a locking tremelo but just rhythm. The music style is just regular "Back Street Boys' style.
 
I think to push things forward, what about a "boy band", 5 guys, they can all sing really well, 4 of them play ukeleles and they're REALLY good...uke solo's out the ying-yang, the 5th guy plays a Jackson with a locking tremelo but just rhythm. The music style is just regular "Back Street Boys' style.

Hmm, boy bands playing guitar you say. Sounds like Simple Plan and Fall out boy and My chemical romance to me. They've been around, you just missed them.:hiding:
 
The current state of affairs in the record industry is only going to make it harder for a radically different sound to emerge from the mainstream ranks. With illegal downloading cutting into profits, the prevailing attitude is to play it safe when signing new bands.

That's not to say that there isn't great stuff out there. I really dig Hella which, as their name would imply, are a band from my neck of the woods. But I'm afraid they are too different to ever garner major exposure.

Also, remember that many groundbreaking albums came from established artists that had the luxury of experimentation. The Beatles couldn't have started with Revolver. Likewise with Angel Dust from Faith No More or Kid A by Radiohead. And sometimes being an established artist isn't enough to give you the right to try something new. After all, Wilco's best album (Yankee Hotel Foxtrot) was deemed unmarketable by their label who dropped them.

But as many have already posted, there is no shortage of musicians trying something new. You just have to do a little more legwork to find them because there's less and less chance of it ending up on the radio in this day and age.
 
I've seen several people list The Mars Volta as a groundbreaking band so I have to ask: Am I the only one who liked At The Drive-In better?

Which is not to say that I hate TMV, but I do have to be in the right mood to listen to them. It doesn't help that their show opening up for RHCP had some of the worst sound I've ever heard. Now clearly large arenas is not the right venue for such a heavily layered band, but even given that it was an awful show from them.
 
When pushing the envelope means overproduced, overblown, and underplayed, I want no part of it.

You can take 3 excellent musicians and come out with Rush or something that sounds like The White Stripes.

Psychotropic interludes into heavy drug use and degredant behavior, isn't music to me, but the bands of today call it "Ground Breaking"

Give me Rush, Musicianship that isn't hard to listen to, lyrics that make sense, and songs with a hook, not just mindless improvisational overplay. Or nonmusical people who pretend to play because they "LOOK" the part.
 
I've seen several people list The Mars Volta as a groundbreaking band so I have to ask: Am I the only one who liked At The Drive-In better?

Which is not to say that I hate TMV, but I do have to be in the right mood to listen to them. It doesn't help that their show opening up for RHCP had some of the worst sound I've ever heard. Now clearly large arenas is not the right venue for such a heavily layered band, but even given that it was an awful show from them.

I don't like Mars Volta. I did like At The Drive In, though strange you mention bad sound while TMV opened up for RHCP. I felt that ATDI suffered bad sound when I saw them open up for RATM back in 99'.

This post uses too many abbreviations.
 
There are plenty of bands that are pushing the envelope, maybe you just have to stop listening to the radio.

lowsound

*DING* Winner!


Until musicians in rock learn to play, write, and be original, instead of another clone of what's in fashion, you're stuck with rap, whiner crap, and wannabe rock.

I agree. However, as long as record companies keep jamming the same crap down the throats of the unwitting public, and they keep swallowing, commerical radio going to remain stagnant.


You can take 3 excellent musicians and come out with Rush or something that sounds like The White Stripes.

You don't even need 3 for the White Stripes ;)


There certainly are fantastic musicians out there making new and different music every day. If you search for it, you will find it...and it won't be on commercial radio.
 
For all the talk about bands being original, the fact remains that to some degree, every band is a product of their influences. In fact, I had this conversation with a friend, stating that I could divine the major influences of pretty much any band he named.

We looked them up later, but I was pretty spot on for 9 of the 10, with Alice In Chains being one that stumped me. (I still couldn't tell you their influences even after a modicum of research)

Point being, the idea of being totally original or new is a bit misleading. Every band stands on the shoulders of giants to some extent. But it is worth noting that pretty much every artist or group that I really dig have big ears and draw from a lot of disparate influences.
 
Here's a few bands from Milwaukee and the surrounding area that i think are pushing musical envelopes.
This Specific Dream - Link Removed
Masonry - Link Removed
Mahogany Throttle - Link Removed
Asrava - Link Removed
Concentric - Link Removed
Things Falling Apart - Link Removed
vonFrickle - Link Removed

enjoy the tunes!!!
-James
 
indie is a broad genre of non-mainstream somewhat experimental music. It can be acoustic or rock or electro (to an extent).
If by "somewhat experimental" you mean "boring, sentimental to the point of being sappy and extremely difficult to enjoy" I'll agree with you. None of that stuff is really my cup of tea...

I should know, I'm from Toronto... indie is basically all that the majority of people my own age listen to around here. Especially considering that this city's demographic of twenty-somethings is primarily comprised of pretentious University students...

The future of music, I think, will be better off without major labels churning out twenty versions of the same band, regardless of the genre.


yea in Toronto. Personally i think that Canadian and alot of amercan indie is exactly how you describe. Canadians are only good in the more "musical" and "technical" genres IMO. Rufus Wainwright best Canadian musician EVER and he one of the worlds best IMO

good indie comes mostly from the UK. Bristol, London and Glasgow spawn great fun post punk indie rock bands. Australia also has great indie bands.



oh and Zilli Misik are pretty awsome. I love the world feel