My favourite demoes of a VI-type instrument (quotecoded for a more compact post):
_______
In practice, if the lowest voice is below C2 you need to put increasing distance between it and the second lowest. Even more in practice, if the lowest note of the chord you're playing is between frets 0 and 4 you'll have to leave the A string unplayed.
Oh, and no, yes, you can play 2-finger, bass-style pizzicato on a VI.
_______
However, what you've conclusively proven is that a/one P-bass, with a specific string complement, doesn't sound like one specific pickup setting (which, by the way?) of a/one bass-VI, also with its own typical-ish (if not set in stone per se) string set.
I would expect a similar amount of variation between any two 4-string bass models.
(Stevie jam ends at 2:43 mark.)
This one doesn't suck either:
Among other observations, a little library of famous parts originally recorded with one:
One more for good measure:
_______
Experience says that, in the lowest register of a VI, you cannot do exactly anything you do on a standard-tuned guitar, the same way as a pianist can't simply move chord voicings that are normal up top indefinitely downward: any given interval, even a consonant one, starts sounding bad past a certain point (look up "critical bands").[A]ll guitar riffs and chords a guitarist knows can be played(albeit an octave lower) and that's works well for some scenarios. While the notes are the same as a bass, there's a reason most gigging bassists don't use one as their main instrument. Also string spacing too tight to be played in the normal way we think of with fingers. Of course it could be played fingerstyle like guitar.
In practice, if the lowest voice is below C2 you need to put increasing distance between it and the second lowest. Even more in practice, if the lowest note of the chord you're playing is between frets 0 and 4 you'll have to leave the A string unplayed.
Oh, and no, yes, you can play 2-finger, bass-style pizzicato on a VI.
_______
Ah, hard facts for a change. Thank you.P Bass freq response when plucking and open E string (34" scale, .105 gauge string) - plugged straight into the interface, no amp/mic/pedal in between. Tone controls set flat.
View attachment 4486522 :
Bass VI freq response when plucking an open E (30" scale, .095 gauge string) - plugged straight into the interface, no amp/mic/pedal in between. Tone controls set flat.
View attachment 4486529
However, what you've conclusively proven is that a/one P-bass, with a specific string complement, doesn't sound like one specific pickup setting (which, by the way?) of a/one bass-VI, also with its own typical-ish (if not set in stone per se) string set.
I would expect a similar amount of variation between any two 4-string bass models.
Last edited:
