• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Stingray compared to Tribute G&L

Hello everyone.

This is my first time here and I am looking for a bit of advice. I am a very casual bass player (1-3 hours a day), learned most songs by ear of with tabs, I like to play songs from Sting, Rush, and I wish I had the talent to play dream theater but that's asking for a lot :)

I used to own a US made G&L L-2000 bass which I had to sell because of money problems. I really liked it, the shape, the sound, the lack of pick guard, everything.

When I had a few dollars available, I bought a used Geddy Lee Jazz bass which I kept for a few months but never really liked it. First is that I like things to be new when it comes to something personal like a bass, and although it sounded great, the neck is really small and I missed having an active bass.

I was offered a trade for the Geddy lee, a 2008 US made Stingray and I really like it. It feels similar to the G&L, sounds amazing, and the neck is great for me. I figured I'll trade and even if I don't like it, I can sell it.

Now that I have the Stingray, I'm really asking myself if I would make a mistake to sell it to buy the G&L Tribute GTS. I know the tributes are great and good enough for the use that I make, but I wonder how a tribute G&L will compare to the Stingray. I have a feeling that if I sell the MusicMan to get the tribute exactly how I like it, I might like the no pickguard look but what if there is a big difference in sound and feel from the fact that it's a tribute.

Any thoughts on how a used Stingray will compare to a new G&L GTS Tribute?

Thank you
 
I have owned both a Tribute L2000 and currently have an '99 SR5. I really liked the L2K, but it didn't have as much personality as the StingRay. Pn the other hand, it wasn't as aggressive, which can be a good thing with some material. In the end, I sold the Tribute once I got a good Precision, and the P and the SR5 pretty much cover whatever I want to do.

WildWillies4.jpg


P1010005_zps9996d553.jpg