I remember back in the 90's when the "boom/twinkle" bass sound (as we used to call it) was all the Rage. I assume that's the "divisive" Stingray sound the OP was referring to: bass and treble cranked, mids scooped, bright round wound strings, aggressive playing. The Stingray can do that well, but I never cared for that sound. Back then I owned a '78 Stingray and understood that it could do so much more than that. In fact, I think of that sound as an affectation rather than the norm for a Stingray.
My overall favorite bass sound of all time is on Supertramp's 1978/79 Breakfast In America album (and tour), which--on every track--is a Stingray (2 band eq) with flat wound strings. I can appreciate most of the many different approaches to bass tone, but the tone on that album is closest to what I personally strive for, and a Stingray gets me there.