• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Stingray vs. Sterling? This what EBMM has to say.

BigBigGuy44

Supporting Member
Jul 29, 2009
3,609
7,297
Happy Valley, PA
Lot of threads recently about these two basses. Just saw this in an email from EBMM and thought it was worth sharing. Enjoy!

StingRay Bass vs. Sterling Bass Comparison
By [Invalid or Expired Link Removed] on February 7, 2017 in Featured Posts, Instruments, Top Stories Posts

Here at Music Man we’ve become known for our heritage of quality bass guitars. From the long-running flagship StingRay Bass to the futuristic envelope pushing Bongo Bass, we’ve always had a consistent vision to fulfill the needs of the discerning bassist, as well as push the instrument forward. Today we’re going to shine the spotlight on two particular lines of basses: the StingRay and the Sterling.

Both of these instruments are tremendous tools in capable hands; deciding which one most closely meets your needs as a player comes down to a number of factors, which we break down in detail below.

StingRay.png


Sterling.png


Body
The StingRay body shape is iconic, with its telltale egg-shaped pickguard and chrome control plate. Both the Sterling and StingRay lines of basses feature Ash bodies with high gloss polyester finishes. The Sterling Bass, however, features a slightly more compact body than the StingRay, measuring in at 1 inch shorter in both length and width, saving 5oz overall in weight. The Sterling also forgoes the control plate, mounting the control knobs directly to the instrument’s body.

StingRayBody.jpg


SterlingBody.jpg


Electronics
The StingRay features a famously punchy custom-wound Music Man single bridge humbucker in its original configuration, and was the first production bass at the time of its release to feature an onboard active preamp EQ. The Sterling model builds on that innovation by including a 3-way pickup selector that allows the user to select between either a series or parallel configuration for the humbucker, as well as a coil tap that allows the humbucker to act as a single coil with hum canceling. Sterling models also feature a ceramic pickup magnet, whereas StingRay models come equipped with Alnico magnets.

StingRayPreamp.jpg


SterlingPreamp.jpg


Neck Design
The StingRay has evolved from Leo Fender’s original design to feature a sturdy 6-bolt neck joint design, whereas the Sterling incorporates Music Man’s 5-bolt neck joint to allow for for our sculpted ergonomic neck joint that Ernie Ball Music Man guitars have become famous for.

The Sterling also features a narrower neck width at the nut, providing for an easier playing experience for those with smaller hands. This neck option is also available on the standard StingRay 4, known as the “SLO Special” for those in-the-know.

StingRayBack.jpg


SterlingBack.jpg


The Verdict
The StingRay has become iconic worldwide for its use as an invaluable tool for both funk and rock bassists for the last four decades, notably used by bass icons such as Louis Johnson, Flea, and Rick James. The Sterling bass has continued the innovations set down by the StingRay and has kept them moving forward.

If you’re looking for a classic, industry-standard bass that has stood the test of time, grab yourself a StingRay. If you’re looking for something just a bit smaller with updated electronics and a more ergonomic neck joint, that also features a more aggressive sound with pronounced midrange presence, the Sterling has your name all over it.



Bonus Content
You’ve read the specs and seen the photos, now hear for yourself what these two incredible basses sound like by watching their demo videos below, featuring bassist Joe Dart of Vulfpeck:



 
Last edited:
I have both. I like the heft of the Stingray (both physically and sonically), but the Sterling has a great modern attack, and it's silver sparkle, so it is quite the struggle for supremacy in this household. Although I try not to let either of them know that it's the Jazz that usually ends up at the gigs.
I often use the word "HEFT" to describe tone! Some people won't understand
the term in regards to bass, but I understand what you mean.

The SUB doesn't have the heft of the Sterling, and the Sterling
doesn't have the heft of the Stingray.
My opinion was formed after I a/b'd the three basses!
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Dr. Cheese
I havent played the SUB basses enough to warrant an opinion but I've played the Ray34/35'a and I've never been able to coax any tone I could appreciate out of it. Muddy pickup/electronics in my opinion. Hoped for some semblance of EB StingRay somewhere in there but never found it. Even the OLPs of old sounded better to me.
 
It would be great if EB morphed the two...
A Stingray with the 3-way switch and Alnico pickup (like the SR 5)...but keep the oval PG (not like the SR 5...)

I'd love to, one day, get another Stingray, but am leaning more towards the Sterling for the added versatility... but I like the heft of the Stingray...
 
I play both basses in a modern country band. I like the Sterling better for smaller rooms, or when I'm not sure of the PA, or the acoustics of the room. I have an easier time placing it in the mix. If I know I'm playing a big venue with really good subs then the Stingray wins. It just has a fat low end that just sounds so good in a big system.
 
I wonder why the Stingray is still way more popular with rock bassists when it’s the Sterling that has the louder and more aggressive sound...Just when I thought I wanted a Stingray, I played a Sterling. I even liked it better than the new Stingray Special I played. Also really like the ability to switch between series, parallel and single coil on the Sterling and I don’t mind the 38mm nut width because of the wider 11 inch radius, as opposed to the 9.5 radius on a Jazz. I will end up with a Stingray at some point but I ended up ordering a used SB14 at a killer price!
 
Hi,
The slo Stingray is no more manufactured, so i can't have one, so here's two solutions for me to have a Stingray sound with a Sterling neck.
1 solution): i just see today that the Sterling 4 H exist with alnico magnets, ( not only ceramic), very good news.
Is there the same pick up like the Stingray alnico's standard or classic ? ( i dont like ceramic or neodynium).
2 solution ) : i know a luthier who cuts the sleeve of a Stingray to make a handle (transform or become) the size of a Sterling neek dimension :-)
What's the best think i would do ?..., because i can't test the sound of the 2 basse's at the same time !
Thank's for the answer's.
 
Hi,
The slo Stingray is no more manufactured, so i can't have one, so here's two solutions for me to have a Stingray sound with a Sterling neck.
1 solution): i just see today that the Sterling 4 H exist with alnico magnets, ( not only ceramic), very good news.
Is there the same pick up like the Stingray alnico's standard or classic ? ( i dont like ceramic or neodynium).
2 solution ) : i know a luthier who cuts the sleeve of a Stingray to make a handle (transform or become) the size of a Sterling neek dimension :)
What's the best think i would do ?..., because i can't test the sound of the 2 basse's at the same time !
Thank's for the answer's.
….writing error occurrs..only ceramic on the Sterling...