Sidecar,
You, of course, are absolutely correct! I was extremely harsh; however, I was severely disappointed.
One would think that many years of playing and experience with many different basses would teach an old dog to expect the unexpected, but again, it’s hard to teach an old dog new tricks.
With all of that being said, I agree with your analysis. I should have been much more objective and analytical with my report. However, before I readdress the issue, let me give you a little background information.
As I stated above, my first upright bass, with which I fell in love, was a 1930’s 4/4 Juzek. The experience of listening to this bass being played was what converted me from electric to upright. Its tone and presence was marvelous! I tried many different strings on it, but got the best sound and response using the Thomastik Weich strings. These strings brought out the depth and soul of this instrument better than any that I had tried.
When I converted this bass to 5 string, I was a little disappointed to find that Thomastik did not have a B string available in the Weich style. Thru the years I tried many different brands, including the D’Addario Helicore, but never experienced as good of a sound until I tried the Innovation Honey strings.
During this time frame I had also acquired a Christopher 7/8 size 5 string and begun to use it for my “working” bass. I had also been using the Thomastik Weich on this bass until I discovered the Innovation strings. I had gone thru two or three sets of these when I started looking for an alternative, which caused me to open the discussion on this page.
As I stated, I was expecting, or at least hoping for, a sound similar to what I had experienced on that bass using either the Thomastik Weich or the Innovation Honey strings. But, it was not even close!
It did not give me the ring and tonality for which I was hoping and I was very displeased to find that it was not a matched set, but rather the same situation that I experienced with Thomastik when I converted to 5 strings; in that, they only offered the B string in the orchestral version and it was physically different in sound and looks to the Weich strings.
Out of frustration, I grabbed the only unused set of strings that I had on hand and changed them just before departing to my evening gig. I used a set of D’Addario Helicore Orchestral Series strings just to get me thru the evening.
Well, to my supprise, my Christopher sounded wonderful last evening! I even got some favorable comments from the other players concerning the lively sound of my upright. And applause from the audience after solos. It was great!
That being said, it just goes to prove that different strings sound different on different instruments. It all depends on how they interact with your ax! So, the Sensicore strings are actually very good, just not on my Christopher bass!
I am sure that others will find the Sensicore Perlon strings wonderful on their instrument, just as I found the D’Addario strings to be wonderful on my Christopher last evening. Again, these same D’Addario strings were absolutely horrible on my Juzek! It all depends on their environment.
And one more note just before I close (and then go stand the corner for my penance. . . . . .)
Question: Do you use a clip on tuner (similar to those used by guitar players) for your bass?
If so, DO NOT PLACE THIS UNIT IN THE AREA OF YOUR TUNNING KEYS (like the guitar players do)! Last evening I reasoned that it would be less obtrusive if I placed my unit there, but it actually caused me to have to tune my strings almost a half tone higher in order to get the correct meter readings. We won’t go into explaining the physics of having the unit that far away from the source, but rather it’s best to simply state that one should always have the tuning device as close to the sound post as possible. (like on the bridge!)
Isn’t playing bass fun!