• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

talk boxes.

Id like to hear a clip of any bassist attempt to use one.

I imagine it would sound nothing like talking.

Ive just recently thought of this combination (bass and talk box)

and not any interest to buy this, as the result would probably be horrible, but just as an interesting conversation.

any body tried it?
or perhaps a clip would be suitable?
 
Actually, here is a comment Bongo made. I think he is on the money here:

OK, check it: For a vocoder to work properly, the formant-sensing channel (vocal input) needs to have resonant peaks within the frequency range of the instrument channel. Otherwise you get silence. What this guy did was only play notes within his vocal range, which was mostly (though not entirely) on the treble end of the neck, on the high strings. Also his EQ had a very prominent high-frequency emphasis, to bring out both a "super Jazz bass" tone, as well as providing the maximum high-freq content for the vocoder to process (within his vocal range). And note that even with all of that, it sounded like crap, completely without low end or guts or any other tonal quality associated with bass. So I'm saying vocoder does not work with bass, unless you play only the "guitar notes", and only vocalize in the range you play, and don't mind it sounding gutless, high, and nasal.

The rest of his performance sounded fantastic though, he's an excellent player with groove and taste.