• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Talking while playing exercises

I am not aware of any exercises to work on this skill.

I think some people have a “multi track brain” and some people don’t.

I myself am able to talk or sing independently while playing bass, without compromising either. I tend to characterize this as the ability to multi track thoughts, but I suspect that if we could analyze what is actually going on in our brain when it occurs, what we would find is, in fact, that our mind is ping-ponging back-and-forth between two tasks so fast, that it seems like multi tracking.

So, although it does not happen with me, I can sympathize. I have seen bassists flub their singing, and singers flub their bass playing. Especially when the parts run contrary to each other. Like when the bass plays on the beat, but the lyrics are upbeats.

but if I imagine people who have trouble with this, the only thing I can think of to help the situation, is practice. Starting off simple and getting progressively harder. The same practice concept I would use to tackle any difficult skill.

On the simple end: play mindless scales while reading aloud from a book. Record yourself. Listen back. How well did your playing come off? Medium difficulty: try having a phone conversation while playing a bass part. Advanced: talk extemporaneously while playing a new song.

As a helpful note, one thing I have noticed speakers do while playing bass, is pausing on beat one to make sure they get the new chord change correct. Then they resume speaking while they are marking time on the instrument. It could be a silent pause, or as simple as inserting ah or um.

At the very least before tackling any of this, make sure that you know the bass part you are playing, and that you know what you are going to say. If you can do them both independently perfect, it follows that you will do better trying to integrate them.

Best of luck in your multi tracking endeavors.
 

Drill it — begin at the beginning — make it easy: one word, one grunt > a series of words — on the beat … off the beat, … everywhere; diversify > add melody, nuance, meter, harmony, expression, argument, stage-banter, poetry, to what is, in effect, the score, as a whole, whether you see it that way or not. You'll get there.
 
Hello,
I am comfortable enough in most live situation I’ve been on but ask me to talk and all comes tumbling down.

I am looking for your recommended exercices to talk at the same time I play (which can come handy in many live context)
Thanks

Yep, for a long time I thought I couldn't do both... I felt exactly the same way as you, Ope. And I've always thought singing while playing is a little tougher for bassists because the vocals don't usually follow what you're playing quite as much as they do with other instruments.

But, then I got into a situation like you where I had to step up and cover some background vocals.

First, I had to come to grips that I use too much of my brain when playing and teach myself how to divorce myself from that some and instead play and sing from feel and muscle memory. Then, I learn the basics of both parts individually. I don't spend too much time on this because I want to develop a unified feel for both parts and how they interact... so, I move pretty quickly onto playing and singing the parts together. I won't lie to you, it usually sounds and feels pretty bad at first. But, with reps, it usually comes together. After I lock it all in, it's kinda funny that I have more trouble playing those bass lines when I'm also not singing... various pieces of parts are cueing each other. I started with simple songs, but now I'm to the point now where I can carry lead on some songs, and even on some more challenging songs like Rush.

The idea might seem overwhelming now, but with the right attitude, approach, and reps, you stand a good chance of being able to pull this off! Maybe my approach will work for you, maybe another will... either way, good luck!
 
  • Like
Reactions: VerryBerry
Hello,
I am comfortable enough in most live situation I’ve been on but ask me to talk and all comes tumbling down.

I am looking for your recommended exercices to talk at the same time I play (which can come handy in many live context)
Thanks

Call your mom, play every song you know and have a conversation. Or someone close ya known, from experience no joke. I'm now comfortable with 2nd vocals in my band
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dbaaase
Hello,
I am comfortable enough in most live situation I’ve been on but ask me to talk and all comes tumbling down.

I am looking for your recommended exercices to talk at the same time I play (which can come handy in many live context)
Thanks
You just do it. It comes easier with time
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dbaaase
Some songs will be relatively hard to talk over and some will be relatively easy. My only advice: If possible, choose a song that's relatively easy to talk over.


The more you do it, the easier it should get.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dbaaase
In my opinion, bass is the hardest (non-wind) instrument to sing along while playing. It took me years to work on backups and then I got to sing lead on a few tunes. Some are just impossible for me to get, due to rhythmic conflicts between the bass line and melody. When you get it down, it is a great feeling because your are on both the bottom and the top of the tune.
 

Latest posts