• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

TB'rs with trucks vs SUVs....

Why not get a 4Runner instead of a Tacoma? Then the gear is in the AC as well, and it’s harder to steal. Certain year range Tacomas don’t have locks on the tailgate…
I dig 4Runners. But at least where I live they are crazy expensive, even older used ones. Out of my budget. IK they can run forever, but I'm going for affordable this time around, used, no car payment, etc etc.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wasnex
My father and his father had a Chevy Astrovan and the GMC equivalent, respectively. To my mind, those things were perfect for transporting stuff and still being drivable.
Yeah, the SUV was a step backwards. Most people never use them off-road. Minivans got the "soccer mom" stigma, so the soccer moms now all drive SUV's.

With that said, a minivan with the features of an SUV, such as active cruise control, would be superb.
 
Thanks for the input, Good stuff everybody, all the same considerations I've bounced around. In the end, pretty much anything will work, even if I had my whole rig in there: a compact 2x12, a 1x12, small case with a head and cables, and a bass or two. Most of the time it's a 1x12 and one bass. I'll never be the guy bringing a PA, drums, anything else like that. Will never need a bigger bass rig that I have now. Heck as Micguy says sometimes I don't need a bass rig at all. We will see.....
 
I dig 4Runners. But at least where I live they are crazy expensive, even older used ones. Out of my budget. IK they can run forever, but I'm going for affordable this time around, used, no car payment, etc etc.

That’s a good way to be…
well, tacos are just as expensive as 4Runners! Unfortunately Toyotas hold value. I love my 06 tundra and 11 Camry.
 
  • Like
Reactions: pbass2
I had trucks as my daily driver for 24 years. It was necessary when we built our house and turned five acres of corn field into a nice livable space. I now drive a Mazda CX-5 which was designed to carry two 1x12 Subway cabs and the rest of my gig gear perfectly in the back cargo area. My wife's CRV cannot do this.

Anyway, I no longer need a truck as long as I have at least one friend with a truck. :D
 
  • Like
Reactions: pbass2
When I moved to AR from WA I traded my new SUV for a 8 year old minivan. A Dodge Grand Caravan RT. I did that for my old dogs and gear. I thought I would sell it for a truck when I got here but found it very useful so I still drive it. Dual sliding doors and fold down seats makes it easy to carry large items.

It is kinda ballsy and has self leveling suspension so it handles the twisty roads well too.

I am comfortable with myself and don't worry what anybody thinks of minivans.
 
Minivans make so much sense, but wife absolutely refuses to own one. Not sure why there’s a stigma against them but it’s real lol.

If I were you, I’d go with a 5-20 year old 4Runner. 4 dr hardtop Jeep would work too, but they aren’t the most comfortable rig for trips over 1 hour IME. The covered area is the way to go though.

Ideally, they still made full size 2 door Blazers and Jimmys.
 
  • Like
Reactions: pbass2
I'm in the market for a new(used) vehicle. Coming from a Subaru Outback which has been totally fine for schlepping my basses and amp. I'm kinda jonesin' for a truck with a shell, though I know another SUV type thing makes more sense for gear transport (better security, your gear is inside the vehicle, etc). But still, trucks are fun(have had them - had a couple Nissan Frontiers - in the past many moons ago). I don't have a work need for a truck, I just like them. My vehicle needs are for getting my gear to gigs (at biggest it's a couple 2x12 cabs) and sessions (just did one where I brought 5 basses), and then road trips, some camping, groceries, maybe some bags of mulch for my gardener wife--nothing an SUV can't handle just as well. If I got a truck, I would get a 4-door crew cab with a shell, because my impression is most truck beds aren't that deep/tall, and my bass cabs on their side are too tall for a tonneau cover (I don't like putting my cabs flat on their back/front). (Are shell locks any better these days than when I had one back in the 90's? You could break into that thing with a screwdriver). Basses would usually go in the cab back seat for best protection. IK it'll work fine most of the time. I live in Cali where the weather is decent year-round FWIW. I'm thinking Frontier or Tacoma crew cab or similar (with shell). Don't need a full-size truck. All that said, overall an SUV is technically a better fit for my purposes--but I want a truck! So, who wants to talk me out of a truck?!
When I had an older Mercedes A-class that proved to not be quite enough internally, I looked quite seriously at a covered trailer as that also potentially allowed for putting gear on trolleys and loading it in up a low ramp. Then COVID happened, I moved to a house with less driveway but got a slightly bigger car.

A trailer might still be a valid option, provided you can park it.

The other issue was me being right fisted and spending the money for adding a tow hook and finding a cheap, decent trailer on eBay. It would have certainly made moving easier..
 
I have a Ford F-250 crew cab for hauling heavy stuff and pulling a trailer, but the company-supplied Toyota SUV that I’ve been using for gig hauling is going away when I retire at the end of this year. So, needing something economical, comfortable and able to haul a Ampeg 810 and all the trimmings, I picked up a Chevy HHR. Lots of room for gear and a low threshold to the cargo bay. Every other guy in our band has some kind of mini-van, but I like the combination of retro, sporty and cargo room that this supplies. 32 mpg ain’t bad either!

IMG_4969.jpeg

IMG_4972.jpeg
 
I have a Ford F-250 crew cab for hauling heavy stuff and pulling a trailer, but the company-supplied Toyota SUV that I’ve been using for gig hauling is going away when I retire at the end of this year. So, needing something economical, comfortable and able to haul a Ampeg 810 and all the trimmings, I picked up a Chevy HHR. Lots of room for gear and a low threshold to the cargo bay. Every other guy in our band has some kind of mini-van, but I like the combination of retro, sporty and cargo room that this supplies. 32 mpg ain’t bad either!

View attachment 7301234
View attachment 7301250
Built on the same platform as the Cobalt. I have an HHR sitting in my driveway that I'm fixing up to sell at some point.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bergerman
If I were you, I’d go with a 5-20 year old 4Runner.
I'm guessing you live somewhere that road salt isn't a factor. Around here (Western NY) the only 20 year old 4Runners you see are in the junkyard.

And even in a non salted state, if you buy something that old I hope you're handy with a wrench.
 
Minivans make so much sense, but wife absolutely refuses to own one. Not sure why there’s a stigma against them but it’s real lol.

If I were you, I’d go with a 5-20 year old 4Runner. 4 dr hardtop Jeep would work too, but they aren’t the most comfortable rig for trips over 1 hour IME. The covered area is the way to go though.

Ideally, they still made full size 2 door Blazers and Jimmys.
I always heard Jeeps weren't that mechanically reliable, and expensive to repair....
 
I drove two different Jeeps as daily drivers..a 2015 and a 2021 from 2016 until May this year. Zero mechanical repairs. Each of those took 14-16 hour drives CO and AZ and hit the trails. Then drove home. 3.6 Pentastar engine. Also, my son drove a separate 2015 for 2 years (126K to 153K miles) as a daily driver in HS. He now has my 21. I would have bought a new one but the prices are insane…the GMC Sierra with rebates was cheaper and way more comfortable for the family.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Kevan Campbell
Well, this is TalkBass, isn't it? Why would the answer be any different than trying to choose between two different basses? In other words, get both!
Pretty much the theory that I subscribe to....
I have four Silverados..... 98, 03, 05 and an 07.
Two Camaros...... 79 & 81
Two Subaru Foresters.... 17 & 21
One El Camino.... 68 SS396 (real 138 and not a clone).
One 09 Corolla...
One 2010 HHR...
One 03 Mustang convertible....
And a huge 79 Blazer...
 
I'm a truck guy, but an SUV would be just fine. A couple buddies have PT Cruiser and Chevy HHR and they hold a lot of gear.

I have a '02-'04-'06 V6 Toy Taco 4x man 5 speed with an ARE cap that holds a lot. Cap has a side opening door in back, or can unlatch back panel and lift whole panel up. I can carry all the gear for my two bands = 2 combos, drums, PA and misc. Can also carry the 4 peeps in each band.
Sits a little high but can easily muscle big cabs in = Sunn 215 Concert cab. Have carpeted plywood over bed floor.

toy taco.png

My wife has a lil' 4 door 2003 Buru Baja pup. Fun truck but the bed with tailgate up is only 3+ feet -- 5' with gate down and extender cage. Good enuff to carry a couple of combos. Throw the bass and guitars in the backseat.

R.jpg
 
Not a mini-van per se, but a small work van: the Dodge Ram Promaster City—everyone wants mine. Good mileage, secure. There was a recall that meant replacing the engine, which was reliable but burned oil (no smoke). So it's possible to find one with 120k miles, but only 50k on the engine.
 
I've got a truck. It tows the trailer with all the band gear/PA/lights, etc. I've got a rig that lives in the rehearsal space and a rig at home. When I'm transporting without the trailer, it's just my bass, maybe a different pedalboard layout. Easily rides shotgun in the truck. If I was constantly transporting my cabs to rehearsal or gigs independent of band gear/trailer, I'd probably have an SUV or station wagon type vehicle.