The Best Bass - a game

[Would'e?]

Looks like Jeff Martinez didn't understand the rules and changed a whole lot of numbers. Can anyone fix that? Perhaps Jeff and Dragonlord could delete their posts and we could pickup where we were before Jeff messed it all up.

 

[j-bass-kreep]

7 Fender +
10 Ibanez
12 Spector
3 Warwick -
9 Jackson
9 Gibson
13 Dingwall
11 Rickenbacker
13 Bee
11 Lakland
12 Peavey
10 Yamaha
12 Schecter

 

[StanFan]

7 Fender
10 Ibanez
12 Spector
3 Warwick
8 Jackson -
9 Gibson
13 Dingwall
11 Rickenbacker
13 Bee
11 Lakland
12 Peavey
11 Yamaha +
12 Schecter

 

[Risen Ashes]

8 Fender
11 Ibanez
13 Spector
4 Warwick
9 Jackson -
8 Gibson
12 Dingwall
12 Rickenbacker
12 Bee
10 Lakland
13 Peavey
10 Yamaha +
13 Schecter

 

[bbates77]

Okay...
- Post #19 is the most recent correct post
- I'm ignoring post #20 as it didn't follow a single rule
- I'm ignoring post #21 as it altered twice for + and -
- Post #23 +1 to Fender and -1 to Warwick
- Post #24 +1 to Yamaha and -1 to Jackson
- Post #25 was altered, but still +1 to Yamaha and -1 to Jackson

Which leave the results as:

9 Fender
9 Ibanez
12 Spector
3 Warwick
7 Jackson
10 Gibson
11 Dingwall
12 Rickenbacker
13 Bee
11Lakland
11 Peavey
12 Yamaha
11 Schecter

I have rewritten the rules in the first post for clarification. I didn't actually think I would need to, as we did had twelve correct posts on the first page.

Here is my entry:

9 Fender
9 Ibanez
13 Spector +
3 Warwick
7 Jackson
10 Gibson
11 Dingwall
12 Rickenbacker
13 Bee
11 Lakland
11 Peavey
11 Yamaha -
11 Schecter

 

[Would'e?]

9 Fender
9 Ibanez
13 Spector
2 Warwick -
7 Jackson
10 Gibson
11 Dingwall
12 Rickenbacker
13 Bee
11 Lakland
12 Peavey +
11 Yamaha
11 Schecter

Thanks for the fix Ben. I'm sue there will be more you'll need to do.

Read the rules people!

 

[IconBasser]

9 Fender
10 Ibanez +
13 Spector
1 Warwick -
7 Jackson
10 Gibson
11 Dingwall
12 Rickenbacker
13 Bee
11 Lakland
12 Peavey
11 Yamaha
11 Schecter

 

[Dragonlord]

9 Fender
10 Ibanez
13 Spector
1 Warwick
7 Jackson
10 Gibson
12 Dingwall +
12 Rickenbacker
12 Bee -
11 Lakland
12 Peavey
11 Yamaha
11 Schecter

 

[bbates77]

Musicman (11) was left off in post #18. Please add.

 

[gottawalk]

9 Fender
9 Ibanez-
13 Spector
2 Warwick+
7 Jackson
10 Gibson
12 Dingwall
12 Rickenbacker
12 Bee -
11 Lakland
12 Peavey
11 Yamaha
11 Schecter

 

[andysick]

9 Fender
9 Ibanez
13 Spector
2 Warwick
7 Jackson
10 Gibson
12 Dingwall
12 Rickenbacker
12 Bee
11 Lakland
12 Peavey
11 Yamaha
10 Schecter -
10 Modulus +

 

[bbates77]

Man, this thread's high maintenance

-1 on Bee in post #31 brings it down to 11,
Modulus should begin on 11 because it was voted for in post #32
and Musicman was left out in post #18 and no-one added it back

therefore the scores are:

9 Fender
9 Ibanez
13 Spector
2 Warwick
7 Jackson
10 Gibson
12 Dingwall
12 Rickenbacker
11 Bee
11 Lakland
12 Peavey
11 Musicman
11 Yamaha
10 Schecter
11 Modulus

 

[James Hart]

-1 on Bee in post #31 brings it down to 11,

which is one of 2 negatives in the same post, so I refuse to acknowledge it.




9 Fender
9 Ibanez
13 Spector
1 Warwick -
7 Jackson
10 Gibson
12 Dingwall
12 Rickenbacker
13 Bee +
11 Lakland
12 Peavey
11 Musicman
11 Yamaha
10 Schecter
11 Modulus

 

[bbates77]

Sorry, you are absolutely right, my bad.

...you really don't like Warwick's do you.

 

[James Hart]

...you really don't like Warwick's do you.

I love their tone! I have planned but on hold a bubinga & wenge fretless 6 to mimic their tone. I've played no less than 50 of them over the last decade or so at a local dealer. I can't say I liked any one of them... not even a little.

I've really tried to like them.

 

[bbates77]

9 Fender
9 Ibanez
14 Spector +
1 Warwick
7 Jackson
10 Gibson
12 Dingwall
12 Rickenbacker
13 Bee
11 Lakland
12 Peavey
11 Musicman
10 Yamaha -
10 Schecter
11 Modulus

 

[mellobud]

Sorry Warwick...I just don't like the feel

9 Fender
9 Ibanez
14 Spector
0 Warwick -
7 Jackson
11 Gibson +
12 Dingwall
12 Rickenbacker
13 Bee
11 Lakland
12 Peavey
11 Musicman
10 Yamaha
10 Schecter
11 Modulus

 

[bbates77]

Note: Warwick has been eliminated, leave it on the scoreboard as 0, do not give it points.

 

[iplaybassguitar]

9 Fender
10 Ibanez +
14 Spector
0 Warwick
6 Jackson -
11 Gibson
12 Dingwall
12 Rickenbacker
13 Bee
11 Lakland
12 Peavey
11 Musicman
10 Yamaha
10 Schecter
11 Modulus

 

[StanFan]

9 Fender
10 Ibanez
14 Spector
0 Warwick
5 Jackson -
11 Gibson
12 Dingwall
12 Rickenbacker
13 Bee
11 Lakland
12 Peavey
11 Musicman
11 Yamaha +
10 Schecter
11 Modulus