• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

There, their, they're.

This is another detail that seems to be lost in the new age: bring or take.

You TAKE it with you when you leave here. You BRING it with you when you come.

I will take it with me when I go from here . I will bring it with me when I come to your location.

I keep hearing that "you can't take it with you".

Is it possible that the philosophers just got it wrong grammatically, and meant to say, "you can't bring it with you"?

Because I have some things I'd like to take with me. Like an air conditioner. Just in case.

-
 
  • Like
Reactions: 96tbird
The grammar point I see confusing people the most is the apostrophe. Online and in lots of student papers, people have no idea when to use it and when not to. It's really simpler than people think; it represents letters left out. That's it. Or rather, that IS it. I think what confuses people is the possessive form, like "John's dog." But that's because people used to say, "John, his dog," so the apostrophe shows that you're contracting "his."

I've struggled with this one for years, trying to make sense of when to use that apostrophe. This is such a simple and easy to remember explanation.
Thanks bro.

So let's make sure I understand.....
This is Johns bass guitar.
Is that right? I'm not eliminating any letters, so no apostrophe?

-Mike
 
I've struggled with this one for years, trying to make sense of when to use that apostrophe. This is such a simple and easy to remember explanation.
Thanks bro.

So let's make sure I understand.....
This is Johns bass guitar.
Is that right? I'm not eliminating any letters, so no apostrophe?

-Mike

No - "John's bass guitar," because you're contracting "his" to show possession. It's archaic - we never use "his" that way WITHOUT contracting it - but that's what you do. And I don't know why we still use 's for female possession - it's still Susan's bass guitar, not Susan'r - but oh well.
 
No - "John's bass guitar," because you're contracting "his" to show possession. It's archaic - we never use "his" that way WITHOUT contracting it - but that's what you do. And I don't know why we still use 's for female possession - it's still Susan's bass guitar, not Susan'r - but oh well.

OK, got it.
Yeah the his thing threw me off since we don't say it that way. Even as I typed out my example, I fought all urges to add the apostrophe to Johns.

Let's try this again, with a twist....
Correct: Those are John's bass guitars.
Incorrect: Those are John's bass guitar's.
Am I right this time?

-Mike
 
  • Like
Reactions: hrodbert696