• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Time for a change - when walking away feels good

Over the weekend I had a discussion with the other two members of the band I've been playing with for the past 2 years and change. To shorten a long story, we all recognized that I had been disengaged and distant over the past few months, and recognized that it was time for a change. I slept on the discussion and then came back the next morning, letting them know I was certain it was time for me to move on.

Essentially this came down to incompatible priorities and schedules. My early enthusiasm for playing shows has waned as it's becoming more and more of a burden on my health and family for me to be out til the wee hours of the morning. Scheduling has also been a challenge as I discuss evenings I want to be out with my wife; we have two young kids so one of us being out means the other is on the hook for the dinner/bath/bedtime routine. I'm the only one in the band with young kids (lead singer has a teenager) and I'm also the only one with a full time, normal business hours job.

For me the things that weren't working were that I am also the only one with a car that can fit the drum kit, making me the de facto transportation for the band (so leaving early after we finish was never an option). It also became clear to me that I'm the only one who practices to improve technique in my (very limited) spare time; our drummer is competent yet unspectacular, our lead singer has an amazing voice but very basic guitar skills that haven't developed much in the past two years, which limits what we have been able to do.

We realized that what it comes down to is that we have different and incompatible needs; they need someone with the flexibility to play shows as they come up, and I need to be challenged musically without needing to be out late. The separation went amicably and there aren't any hard feelings either way, so overall I am feeling good about this, a touch of sadness but a lot more relief that the pressure and frustration I had been feeling is gone now.

I don't know what comes next. I still love playing music with people so I'll surely seek something out that meets my needs better; I've pretty exclusively played original rock music, but perhaps it's time to look at other options too.

I'll always have a special place in my heart for the time I spent with this band and the music we made. I regret that we never finished the recording project that we started, but so it goes. Moving on now feels right though. If I had decided to push myself and carry on, I think it would have been with resentment festering under the surface. Far better to end things now on a good note and part as friends.
 
“For everything there is a season, and a time for every matter under heaven: a time to be born, and a time to die; a time to plant, and a time to pluck up what is planted; a time to kill, and a time to heal; a time to break down, and a time to build up; a time to weep, and a time to laugh; a time to mourn, and a time to dance; a time to throw away stones, and a time to gather stones together; a time to embrace, and a time to refrain from embracing; a time to seek, and a time to lose; a time to keep, and a time to throw away; a time to tear, and a time to sew; a time to keep silence, and a time to speak; a time to love, and a time to hate; a time for war, and a time for peace.”
‭‭Ecclesiastes‬ ‭3‬:‭1‬-‭8‬ ‭NRSV‬‬
 
Over the weekend I had a discussion with the other two members of the band I've been playing with for the past 2 years and change. To shorten a long story, we all recognized that I had been disengaged and distant over the past few months, and recognized that it was time for a change. I slept on the discussion and then came back the next morning, letting them know I was certain it was time for me to move on.

Essentially this came down to incompatible priorities and schedules. My early enthusiasm for playing shows has waned as it's becoming more and more of a burden on my health and family for me to be out til the wee hours of the morning. Scheduling has also been a challenge as I discuss evenings I want to be out with my wife; we have two young kids so one of us being out means the other is on the hook for the dinner/bath/bedtime routine. I'm the only one in the band with young kids (lead singer has a teenager) and I'm also the only one with a full time, normal business hours job.

For me the things that weren't working were that I am also the only one with a car that can fit the drum kit, making me the de facto transportation for the band (so leaving early after we finish was never an option). It also became clear to me that I'm the only one who practices to improve technique in my (very limited) spare time; our drummer is competent yet unspectacular, our lead singer has an amazing voice but very basic guitar skills that haven't developed much in the past two years, which limits what we have been able to do.

We realized that what it comes down to is that we have different and incompatible needs; they need someone with the flexibility to play shows as they come up, and I need to be challenged musically without needing to be out late. The separation went amicably and there aren't any hard feelings either way, so overall I am feeling good about this, a touch of sadness but a lot more relief that the pressure and frustration I had been feeling is gone now.

I don't know what comes next. I still love playing music with people so I'll surely seek something out that meets my needs better; I've pretty exclusively played original rock music, but perhaps it's time to look at other options too.

I'll always have a special place in my heart for the time I spent with this band and the music we made. I regret that we never finished the recording project that we started, but so it goes. Moving on now feels right though. If I had decided to push myself and carry on, I think it would have been with resentment festering under the surface. Far better to end things now on a good note and part as friends.
You will find something that will be a better fit.
 
Children need their fathers around when they're young. And wives need their husbands to share the load. You absolutely made the right decision.

To be fair to my former bandmates, they absolutely understood this and if I ever had to cancel a rehearsal to take care of a sick kid (or step in for a sick wife), I got no grief from them. But yes, I know it was the right call.
 
Wow, I'm 67 years old. took a huge break at 34 for the kids T-ball, PTA, dance lessons, etc. I literally cried over the decision.

I'm playing again after 20 years and things are different, but it was absolutely
the right call for me and, eventually, 2 other guys in my last "real" band. I wish we could have been as mature as you guys were, since our group had some hurt feelings, etc. But, the end result is a 2 out of 3 of our marriages and 4 kids have turned out okay.

God, I love music and I love playing, but I had other, more important obligations/relationships/promises, and not everyone sees it that way.


Good on you guys!! You've restored my faith in band relationships and that little corner of humanity we call musicians.
 
You made absolutely the right decision on many fronts. Might I suggest that you look for others who have similar family/life situations as you in the future. It's not always easy to find, but if you can find other people in the same 'life place' as you are - it makes it so much easier to make everything line up.

Yep, I have been chewing on this a while and in think it's correct. It's one thing to understand on a theoretical level that family obligations tie your hands a lot, but a totally different thing to live with that every day and understand it on an emotional level too.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LowNotesFish
Drummer without a car expects YOU to carry his kit for him?

"Unprofessional, that's what you [he] are...
Unprofessional, no tux, no car.."

I'd have been done after the first round with that one.

Dude's 43 and never learned to drive. I don't really know why, I asked once and he didn't really want to talk about it. I got the sense it was a tender spot so I didn't scratch. I was ok with it for a while but resentment was slowly building, another good reason to be done.

I wish them good luck finding someone else willing to take that on...
 
overall I am feeling good about this, a touch of sadness but a lot more relief that the pressure and frustration I had been feeling is gone now....Moving on now feels right though. If I had decided to push myself and carry on, I think it would have been with resentment festering under the surface. Far better to end things now on a good note and part as friends.
all good, IMO, i hope you engage with a project that better suits your situation, good luck! :thumbsup:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Isaac_James
Dude's 43 and never learned to drive. I don't really know why, I asked once and he didn't really want to talk about it. I got the sense it was a tender spot so I didn't scratch. I was ok with it for a while but resentment was slowly building, another good reason to be done.

I wish them good luck finding someone else willing to take that on...
A drummer that's 43, has not learned how to drive, and isn't blind? Obvious doofus unless he's epileptic.
 
Over the weekend I had a discussion with the other two members of the band I've been playing with for the past 2 years and change. To shorten a long story, we all recognized that I had been disengaged and distant over the past few months, and recognized that it was time for a change. I slept on the discussion and then came back the next morning, letting them know I was certain it was time for me to move on.

Essentially this came down to incompatible priorities and schedules. My early enthusiasm for playing shows has waned as it's becoming more and more of a burden on my health and family for me to be out til the wee hours of the morning. Scheduling has also been a challenge as I discuss evenings I want to be out with my wife; we have two young kids so one of us being out means the other is on the hook for the dinner/bath/bedtime routine. I'm the only one in the band with young kids (lead singer has a teenager) and I'm also the only one with a full time, normal business hours job.

For me the things that weren't working were that I am also the only one with a car that can fit the drum kit, making me the de facto transportation for the band (so leaving early after we finish was never an option). It also became clear to me that I'm the only one who practices to improve technique in my (very limited) spare time; our drummer is competent yet unspectacular, our lead singer has an amazing voice but very basic guitar skills that haven't developed much in the past two years, which limits what we have been able to do.

We realized that what it comes down to is that we have different and incompatible needs; they need someone with the flexibility to play shows as they come up, and I need to be challenged musically without needing to be out late. The separation went amicably and there aren't any hard feelings either way, so overall I am feeling good about this, a touch of sadness but a lot more relief that the pressure and frustration I had been feeling is gone now.

I don't know what comes next. I still love playing music with people so I'll surely seek something out that meets my needs better; I've pretty exclusively played original rock music, but perhaps it's time to look at other options too.

I'll always have a special place in my heart for the time I spent with this band and the music we made. I regret that we never finished the recording project that we started, but so it goes. Moving on now feels right though. If I had decided to push myself and carry on, I think it would have been with resentment festering under the surface. Far better to end things now on a good note and part as friends.
You did the right thing. Well done on seeing that. Find a band where you're the bassman, with a fair share of the commitment.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Isaac_James

Latest posts