• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Too many choices

Hey all. So I've been playing bass since I was 15 years old, going through a variety of low end starter basses, Ibanez GIO, Squier Standard, and a VM Fretless Jazz, and I'm finally taking a look into mid range basses as an upgrade.While I love my fretless I find myself in need of a fretted bass for other applications, certain songs, and sounds and styles and such.

My current bass is a Squier VM Fretless Jazz w/ Dimarzio Model J pickups and a Gotoh 201 bridge which goes into a Markbass LM Tube 800 and a SWR 4x12 Stack.


I like dual pickups, active/passive tonal controls, 22 frets or more, versatile electronics (no one trick ponies), well placed in a variety of bands. I would prefer a four string as it is what I am comfortable on and only really use, no fretless as I already have one.

I play alot of indie rock (helpful isn't it?), King Crimson/Mars Volta kind of Prog, jazz, some funk/hip hop inspired bass lines. Most important for me is a bass with a lot of deep bottom end, very little hiss/hum, and very, very clear tone.

1) Carvin SB4000

Pros: Classic Jazz bass layout of controls, active eq with passive bypass, customizable, Ebony fingerboard, unique design. All in all a solid bass with many options for uniqueness.
Cons: 20 frets (not a huge deal, but I typically like 22 or 24)

2) Used Fender Roscoe Beck IV

Pros: 2 humbucking splittable pickups, sophisticated layout of controls, incredibly versatile, Drop D tuner (not really a big deal, but neat), 22 frets.
Cons: Expensive ($800 more than the Carvin), Used is more of a waiting game which I will play if well worth it.

3) G&L L2000 USA

Pros: Active/Passive electronics, 2 humbucking pickups wired for series or parallel operation with optional high end boost.
Cons: Kind of ugly tobacco sunburst but there are other options available. Otherwise very little.

4) Fender American Deluxe P Bass

Pros: P/J config with active 3 band eq, 22 frets, comfortable to play.
Cons: Pickup pan pot/master volume, less versatile than G&L or RB Sig.

Open to other suggestions, so long as they meet most of my criteria though I am flexible in my thinking. Budget is $1500 USD or less. I live in Boise, ID and there is not much of a used market for basses.
Thanks for all of your help!
 
I have owned at least 40 different basses over the last 23 years, including a couple of Carvins and lots of Fenders(including a Roscoe Beck), and the G&L L2000 is the one I always come back to. With the K switch (single coil) option, it can do just about any tone you would want (except Stingray). In active mode, it cuts right through the mix in my 12 piece Disco/Funk band better than any other bass, and in passive mode it is the ultimate rock bass!

And no, I do not have an endorsement with them (although that would be nice :D).
 
The more and more I look at the G&L I must say it looks incredibly appealing, however I did just check, my local G&L dealer closed down last year due to the economy, so I'll probably be looking for a used sale which will take alot longer for me to find one where I'm happy with the specs and aesthetics. But what is the neck on the L2000 like? Jazz? Precision? Deep U like Warwicks old models? Honestly at this point I'm really just in between the Roscoe Beck and the L2000. The SB4000 seemed nice but if the G&L can do everything it can do and more then I might as well just go for that.

Also the controls on the L-2000 are just listed as "G&L Tritone Active/Passive electronics". What exactly does that mean? I understand that there is a 3 way pickup selector, a series/parallel selector, and a passive/active/active with high boost selector, but I have trouble finding what the knobs are? Master volume, bass, treble?
 
The G&L has a huge, deep tone that almost always sounds great in a mix. You have coil splitting and EQ options too. Quality of USA models has never been questionable either. The Tributes are great as well, if you want the same sound (exact same electronics as the USA models) for less money, they are MIK i believe.

The controls (from the headstock down)are:

Top knob: Volume
Second: Treb boost
Third: Bass boost

Top switch: Pickup selector (neck, neck+bridge, bridge)
Mid switch: Coil taps (single, humbucking)
Bottom switch: (active/passive/active with Treble Boost)

I thought the controls were great. Real easy to use and navigate once you have the thing for a few days.
 
l2000....unversatile?? You are funny. I guess you know cause you told you so but you don't know like I know.

Yes one volume but also a bass and treble knob, 3 way pick up selector, series parallel, active /active treb/passive. Not versatile........that would be the Pbass danomite (still a great bass style but as one trick pony as they come)
 
SB basses kill, poor mans boutique jazz. Ash and maple configuration has serous bite and the pre boost the lows so well, if you get the j99a single coils. By far the best bang for the dollar, better construction than any g&l I've ever played. Best carvin bass yet because they finally got the electronics right. Just search the net all the session dude love these basses.
 
The Musicman Stingray 4HH is such diverse bass!. The second pick up gives it that sexy low end punch.
Top knob : volume
2nd knob: treble
3rd knob: mids
4th knob: BASS!!
Another cool feature that you normally only see on guitars is the 5-way lever pickup selector. It controls which pick-ups are in use. Its practically 5 more different tones. I'm so happy with mine, it really is a fantastic bass. Happy buying :)
The obvious cons is that it is quite an expensive bass (start saving) and depending where you live the shipping can take some time. Mine was 4 months LOL!