TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Thanks for the input IamgrotNice job, now make your students memorize it, esp sight transposing down a 2nd and up a minor 3rd.
The best result I had over the years, was with my nephew , he wanted to learn bass, he knew I was a lead player but could also play bass, among other things he applied himself and within 3 months was playing with a reasonable band. I am sure you know its very gratifying when students really want to learn how to play "Music" and not want to play "Smoke on the water", or "Stairway to heaven" the first lesson. (Showing my age now ) ha ha. Regards PhilNice job, now make your students memorize it, esp sight transposing down a 2nd and up a minor 3rd.
I concur iamgroot, I never do things in half measure, there is no point in that, I used to say to students if you don't understand tell me, I don't care if I go over it 50 times as long as eventually you understand.View attachment 3198010Nice job, now make your students memorize it, esp sight transposing down a 2nd and up a minor 3rd.
I concur iamgroot, I never do things in half measure, there is no point in that, I used to say to students if you don't understand tell me, I don't care if I go over it 50 times as long as eventually you understand.![]()
I suppose in some ways Iamgroot if it wasn't different there would be little point and no challenge, ai think the more instruments you play the more accomplished musician you become. I used to play lead guitar in a jazz quartet the band leader was so good he used to be writing out a whole score while drinking tea and talking to me. Some folk are just incredibly gifted. We all have different methods what we believe as with all things is merely OUR opinion it doesn't mean its etched in stone. What works for one wont for anotherPhil,
Good Luck!!.
My choice on transposition was to allow sight reading horn and wind parts.
I played bass for years behind a jazz singer who would call standards and announce the key right before he counted it off. It was ugly at first, but improved me immensely. He was an olt timer and he was training us on the job.
Now I am a piano student and transposing piano is much more complex than guitar or bass as the fingering changes with each key, especially if you go from a sharp to a flat key. My instructor has perfect pitch and I drive her crazy by playing The Bach WTC Prelude in C....in other keys.
Don't underestimate yourself, do listeners say He's got persistence or He's got talent.? The latter I'm sure.I keep a gut string guitar by my computer for transcribing and to play sheet music on youtube (mostly sax solos). I started playing classical guitar when I was about 5 (which I hated). For some folks - like Tommy Tedesco and me - its not so much talent as sheer persistence.
View attachment 3198828