Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Tuba or Sousaphone?
- Thread starter guroove
- Start date
Hey, I played Sousaphone. Now that this got moved to Misc. don't I get credit on my post count for posts I made before it got moved?
Don't tell that to Dixieland/brass band players. They love their Sousaphones, and the Sousaphone IS more fun to play.
Here's my contras (contrabass clarinet, contrabassoon):
That would be a Sarrusaphone, no?
Reed instruments do not count, sorry. Try again.
The Sousaphone was developed by John Phillip Sousa, the rock star of the late 19th and early 20th century specifically for marching bands. There is no comfortable way to carry a tuba in a marching band.
Of the two, I'd prefer a tuba. I think the tone is better and I don't march anymore.
Of the two, I'd prefer a tuba. I think the tone is better and I don't march anymore.
Bulloney!
Of course, you do. So do I. Sousaphone has its place-jazz bands, marching band, etc.; Tubas have their place-orchestras, brass bands (non-moving or marching), etc. By the way, Sousa devised the "rain catcher"...a sousaphone with an upright bell. This was to disperse the sound of the horn more evenly over the band, so as not to overpower the other instruments. This was Sousa's preference. Later folks like J.W.Pepper and Conn turned the bell forward for other purposes like marching bands, etc.
Last edited:
Actually, J.W. Pepper built the instrument at Phillip's request. I don't know that Conn contributed to the design, but he was the primary maker and Sousa used Conn's instrument in his band.
Sounds like you need to begin a migration to sousaphone or tuba. Slowly at first then accelerate to become a whoom-ass sousaphonist!
