TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
I'm considering (among a lot of other basses) a carved round back Brescian - I'm looking for a big bass that can be a lifelong companion - orchestral pipe organ / jazz canon type of deal.
anyone have one or something similar? would love to hear your thoughts.
I owned one of the earlier UB Hawkes laminate basses. Bought it and went to the woodshed, but that was right before grad school, marriage, new house, new job, move to another house, kid...and sold it after much neglect - the bass people, not the kid! She's a keeper.
I play bass guitar in the church orchestra, but there is a lot of opportunities to play upright ('string') bass pizz and some arco. It has always been a dream of mine to play walking jazz lines on DB. Get a teacher and woodshed at night after dinner.
Moved some gear and now have the cash to cover a UB Standard Laminate. Was considering an old Kay. There is one local I'm going to try and play next weekend. But the price range is very close to a new Upton ply. So I'm very close to plunking down the cash to get the build rolling.
I would go Upton. I don't like those really thin necks on Kays and Engelhardts. Upton's necks are fat, juicy, and extremely easy to play.I owned one of the earlier UB Hawkes laminate basses. Bought it and went to the woodshed, but that was right before grad school, marriage, new house, new job, move to another house, kid...and sold it after much neglect - the bass people, not the kid! She's a keeper.
I play bass guitar in the church orchestra, but there is a lot of opportunities to play upright ('string') bass pizz and some arco. It has always been a dream of mine to play walking jazz lines on DB. Get a teacher and woodshed at night after dinner.
Moved some gear and now have the cash to cover a UB Standard Laminate. Was considering an old Kay. There is one local I'm going to try and play next weekend. But the price range is very close to a new Upton ply. So I'm very close to plunking down the cash to get the build rolling.
I owned one of the earlier UB Hawkes laminate basses. Bought it and went to the woodshed, but that was right before grad school, marriage, new house, new job, move to another house, kid...and sold it after much neglect - the bass people, not the kid! She's a keeper.
I play bass guitar in the church orchestra, but there is a lot of opportunities to play upright ('string') bass pizz and some arco. It has always been a dream of mine to play walking jazz lines on DB. Get a teacher and woodshed at night after dinner.
Moved some gear and now have the cash to cover a UB Standard Laminate. Was considering an old Kay. There is one local I'm going to try and play next weekend. But the price range is very close to a new Upton ply. So I'm very close to plunking down the cash to get the build rolling.
You won't regret going with a new UB Standard Laminate. I looked at some older american basses when I was looking for mine. I had much the same consideration with the price range as well. With a new UB Standard Laminate, you get a brand new american made bass with zero of the stability and other issues an Old Kay may have. That being said, you are not getting any of that "vintage vibe" that may come from a vintage kay with older woods. That may be an important thing for uprights, it may not. I speak from a primarily electric point of view and I know older/vintage wood can be considered a difference. The most important thing I could say about picking one is play each if you can and pick the one that speaks to you. You can talk about potential build quality issues, age of wood, and just about everything else. But at the end of the day, by the one that speaks to musically and sonically. You can buy a brand new UB for a great deal but if it doesn't inspire you to play as much as the Old Kay would then there isn't a point buying a brand new bass. Same can be said vice versa. An upright is an investment in yourself as much as it is a monetary one so buy the bass you feel fits you and will be the one that you can "speak" with better. Hope that helps and good luck finding your next bass!
I would go Upton. I don't like those really thin necks on Kays and Engelhardts. Upton's necks are fat, juicy, and extremely easy to play.
As others have said, you wont regret the Upton if you gonthat route. When I was shopping I looked at several old Kay’s I found on Craigslist. Then when I got to reading - the standard Upton was essentially the same money. I figured it was worth my time to drive to the Upton shop. There I was able to compare several Kay’s, a laminated Shen, and a hybrid Shen and a laminated Upton that they had just completed.
At the time Upton was selling Shen’s as well as the their own in house builds.
No comparison- the laminated Upton was a better bass & better tone than even the hybrid Shen - and all were better than the Kay’s that they had there.
As we were driving home even my wife was telling me I should buy the Upton - That’s something I don’t get very often!
'Preciate the input. I do like the 'charm' but would rather have the hassle-free!Old beat-up Kays have a certain charm, but many I have seen have major problems (some are downright unplayable). I echo the others. You are going to love the hassle-free Upton.
Question for you UB Standard Laminate owners: How brown is this joker? Can you see some grain through the hand-applied finish? Or does it look like it was "polished with a Hersey bar" as they used to say in the Army.

Too brown for me. That's why I paid to have an upgraded birch top veneer on my Bohemian ply so that I could have a lighter finish. Did the same for the sides and back of the Bohemian hybrid Upton.Question for you UB Standard Laminate owners: How brown is this joker? Can you see some grain through the hand-applied finish? Or does it look like it was "polished with a Hersey bar" as they used to say in the Army.
Should have said upgraded top, back and sides on my full ply. Not just the top.Too brown for me. That's why I paid to have an upgraded birch top veneer on my Bohemian ply so that I could have a lighter finish. Did the same for the sides and back of the Bohemian hybrid Upton.