I’m a hard rock/metal bassist influenced by Steve Harris, Cliff Burton and Duff McKagan about to build a Warmoth Jazz bass with the following specs. What do y’all think?
BODY
Chambered mahogany
Flamed maple cap
Pearl pickguard
Red dyed top and black back gloss finish
Chrome hardware
Seymour Duncan quarter pound J/P pickups
Vol/vol/tone/toggle controll layout
Contoured heel
Fender hi mass bridge
Side mounted Stratocaster jack socket (think Ibanez JEM/Jackson Rhodes V/many Explorer-type guitars) to prevent the cable from getting ripped out, should it be stepped on
NECK
Flamed maple neck (vintage tint, satin finish)
Ebony fingerboard
24 stainless steel 6100 frets
No inlays
Luminescent side markers
Hipshot D tuner on E string and Schallers for the 3 others (vintage clover buttons)
Brass nut
I’m after a fairly Traditional looking, unique and versatile bass. Is this it, or am I WAY off? According to what I like in basses (and guitars) as far as woods and hardware this should be it, but maybe I’m missing something?
Only curious about what a toggle control layout would mean? If a toggle is a 3-way pickup switch, I don't know if there's any need for that if it also has vol/vol/tone controls. I guess you could have the J pickup partially blended in - I like playing my P/J like that - and then easily switch between that tone and your solo'ed P pickup, right?
You sound like you've got a honey of a build in mind. Best of luck with it!!
My passive P/J is a neat custom build I found from a TB'er (no info on who crafted it), which has a mahogany body and a very handsome flamed maple top. I can say that I'd never think of covering any of that spiffy top with a pickguard - just my personal preference.
I haven't played an ocean of different instruments through the years and even my P/J experience is limited. I got this bass when I wanted an alternative to my parts Jazz, which I should point out has a Warmoth neck - maple/rosewood and steel rods. That J is rock solid, but too heavy for me (10.5 lbs.) to gig for a full evening. My P/J actually weighs a little more than a pound less than that Jazz, so its heft isn't a nuisance for me and it has a similar rock solid feel and playability.
My Warmoth neck on my Jazz has 21 frets, but the fingerboard extends beyond the heel of the neck by about 7/8" and covers enough of the access to the truss rod fitting that I have to take the neck off the body whenever I want to adjust it. Deal-breaker. I love Warmoth's necks and bodies, but I'll only play another one in the future if I don't have to put up with this.
My P/J also has a maple/rosewood neck, but I'm not ashamed to admit that if I could have my way, I'd love it with an ebony fingerboard. It might be a minor detail, but I don't remember being disappointed with any fretted or fretless bass I've ever tried that had an ebony board. Great call!!
As for its sound, the P/J had active EMG's when I bought it. I eventually got the itch to swap in a passive layout and my first thoughts were to go for DiMarzios or perhaps a set from Aguilar or Lindy Fralin. My luthier pals were very big on Joe Barden products (JBE), so I took their advice, made the investment, and I'm still getting perma-grin when I get to turn up with that bass at a gig. Balanced, rich, and yummy sounding. Just my story.
There are several "right" answers for sure in terms of pickup options and you can always sample something new down the road. If you trust the Seymour Duncans, then that's probably the smart call - you may get some extra confidence with their familiar response and sound.
Come to think of it, my P/J also has a D-tuner and a brass nut. Both features seem to work great. I've really never used anything other than standard tuning, but my band played one tune last summer where that low D came in really handy. Fortunately I don't need to give you the curmudgeon line: "It's MY bass, go build your own!!" You sound like you're on the case
