...I've found in some ways its a one trick pony.
Glad that you've played both, and if the Ric is a one trick pony to you, then get the $$.
$$. A Ric will sound like a Ric basically no matter what you do. It's pretty one dimensional (YMMV).
Does a Jazz sound like a jazz, does a P sound...etc
RIC, and +1- it's not a one-trick-pony, lot's of great tones in there.
+1 A Ric has 2 pups, 2 vol/tone and a vintage/mod tone switch. Mine sounds like a Ric, Jazz, P, Ray and in my book that's more than one trick.