I have said this for years (and on this forum in one way or another) People do notice the difference between a good sounding band and a bad sounding band. Most of the time they have no clue why and sometimes musicians themselves have no clue why. But quality equipment in good repair played by musicians who care trump all else. You don't have to be the best musician in the house, town, state, country or world. You just have to care enough to have good equipment in good repair and really care about your presentation, that will win every time! I could go on and on...but yes SpazzThe Bassist is right on!i kinda disagree with that......What I notice about tone (and this applies to all instruments, not just bass) is that its a "sheen" that the audience notices. You can have two bands of equal caliber, one with guitarists and bassists with fresh strings, using optimal pickup and fx configs for the songs, and a drummer with fresh heads and they will notice that they sound drastically better than a band with dead strings, blues amp setups for every song (including non blues tunes), and drum heads old enough to vote...they may not be able to tell you why, but folks can hear a difference
I will say that bass is probably the most forgiving, hence why there are so many 'set-it-and-forget-it' players because a single good tone can often work with a nights-worth of songs and nobody would notice, but it doesnt mean that a player shouldn't be concerned with tone and not do their part to add to the polish
