• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

What would you do? (Ethical question)

Status
Not open for further replies.
This is not directed at you TinIndian, but I used your post as it is short and to the point...

I see a lot of people take action out of fear of Karmic retribution, but it seems very little people are aware of what Karma truly is. And, unless one believes in the immortality of the soul, Karma should have no bearing on ones actions.

The true results of Karma are not to be seen in this life, but the next.

kar·ma
noun

1.(in Hinduism and Buddhism) The sum of a person's actions in this and previous states of existence, viewed as deciding their fate in future existences

I'm pretty sure he meant karma in the sense that what goes around comes around.
 
Return it. However, call Musician's Friend first, tell them what happened, and since it was their mistake, get them to pay for the return shipping. I hope they credit you in some way for your honesty, but even if they don't, you'll know that you are doing the right thing, and that will be reward enough :)
 
Agreed. I'm just speculating that the amount of shinkage due to this type is situation is minimal compared to damage/disregard/etc. And beyond traditional theft, all this shrinkage is the company's fault. Like the massive MF Rickenbacker sale last year, they were brand new basses that were warped and damaged and yellowed from obvious mistakes in storage. They had to sell em for super cheap, and most of those even got returned for having obvious blemishes or being unplayable. Now that drives up the price of everything else on the site too, but it wasn't our fault. We still have to pay for it.

'Shrinkage' is as common as daylight I'm afraid.
It could also be called 'shipping error', 'billing error', picking error', etc.

I see it each and every day at work, it's a very very very rare day indeed that there isn't an inventory mistake of some kind, and I work at a store with 8 employees, but deal with up to 6 warehouses on most days.
If all parties are not honest with each other soon enough the cost of business is prohibitive, or someone finds out about said dishonesty and employees are fired or end up with criminal records.

If anyone thinks things like this are just 'written off', they are very much mistaken.
Every company counts inventory at regular intervals, and often enact 'unofficial' counts in between 'official' inventory counting sessions.

Any responsible company tries their level best to find out exactly why their inventory is off and correct it accordingly.
This instance shouldn't be too hard to track down.
There are shipping waybills which will not reconcile with billing records, so it's 100% traceable.
 
Having an accurate moral compass is its own reward, without expectation that life will reward you for it.

Recognizing when you are rationalizing is one of many key factors in being honest with yourself. You're not going to get what you want out of life if you can't be honest with yourself and at least one other person.

It is not necessary to believe in Karma or any other kind of cosmic justice. However, it's not a bad idea to stack the deck in your favor purely in terms of cause and effect. Waiters don't spit in everyone's soup.

All of my thoughts on the subject are pragmatic and self-interested, without devolving into superstition or warm fuzzy feelings.
 
Having an accurate moral compass is its own reward, without expectation that life will reward you for it.

Recognizing when you are rationalizing is one of many key factors in being honest with yourself. You're not going to get what you want out of life if you can't be honest with yourself and at least one other person.

It is not necessary to believe in Karma or any other kind of cosmic justice. However, it's not a bad idea to stack the deck in your favor purely in terms of cause and effect. Waiters don't spit in everyone's soup.

All of my thoughts on the subject are pragmatic and self-interested, without devolving into superstition or warm fuzzy feelings.

Great post!

+PF-500
 
Having an accurate moral compass is its own reward, without expectation that life will reward you for it.

Recognizing when you are rationalizing is one of many key factors in being honest with yourself. You're not going to get what you want out of life if you can't be honest with yourself and at least one other person.

It is not necessary to believe in Karma or any other kind of cosmic justice. However, it's not a bad idea to stack the deck in your favor purely in terms of cause and effect. Waiters don't spit in everyone's soup.

All of my thoughts on the subject are pragmatic and self-interested, without devolving into superstition or warm fuzzy feelings.

Well put, D-Man:bassist:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.