- Jun 3, 2009
- 3,330
- 398
- Disclosures
- Bassgearu, Music Industry Consulting and Sales. Tech 21, NBE Corp, Sonosphere.
Generally there is little difference between the quality of MIJ and MIA, considering that Mr. Deming taught the Japanese QC after WWII and now all American companies use his QC principles.
Now, in reality, the MIA is made in a factory owned and operated by Fender. All the other factories are contract, so the QC will be different and also the parts sources vary depending on where they can get them the cheapest. So, Fender made in Mexico is not from a Fender plant, but one licensed by Fender. They might check on the overall production facility once a year.
If you wonder about QC, just remember the Mattel fiasco a year ago with children's toys and lead paint. The Mattel guys contracted for toys with no lead, the plant said no lead but in fact purchased lead based paints. So you have no idea what you really get from foreign made construction.
That is not to say that other countries make bad things. I worked in tennis racquet production for a decade. Just about every tennis racquet on the planet comes from China, including the high end ones. Mostly because the environmental requirements to work with some of the materials here make them cost prohibitive. It may not be right, but China doesn't really have environmental laws yet, so everything is much cheaper.
Also, typically the high end gear, including Fender, is made by Americans in custom shops. So there is a level of pride that the luthier takes on that is unique to the US. Other countries, maybe Germany and the UK the exceptions, look at manufacturing as a mass market commodity. Pride in workmanship doesn't matter as much as it does here.
My two cents...
Now, in reality, the MIA is made in a factory owned and operated by Fender. All the other factories are contract, so the QC will be different and also the parts sources vary depending on where they can get them the cheapest. So, Fender made in Mexico is not from a Fender plant, but one licensed by Fender. They might check on the overall production facility once a year.
If you wonder about QC, just remember the Mattel fiasco a year ago with children's toys and lead paint. The Mattel guys contracted for toys with no lead, the plant said no lead but in fact purchased lead based paints. So you have no idea what you really get from foreign made construction.
That is not to say that other countries make bad things. I worked in tennis racquet production for a decade. Just about every tennis racquet on the planet comes from China, including the high end ones. Mostly because the environmental requirements to work with some of the materials here make them cost prohibitive. It may not be right, but China doesn't really have environmental laws yet, so everything is much cheaper.
Also, typically the high end gear, including Fender, is made by Americans in custom shops. So there is a level of pride that the luthier takes on that is unique to the US. Other countries, maybe Germany and the UK the exceptions, look at manufacturing as a mass market commodity. Pride in workmanship doesn't matter as much as it does here.
My two cents...
