TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Ultimate-Guitar for me, if you play popular music I've found most of the tabs to be fairly accurate.
Leslie West's (RIP) ripping solo in Nantucket Sleighride.
Bredian said:I use ultimate mostly, as it looks like many were consolidated into it OR they've ended up with duplicate submittals. You can tell when a tab is the same work many times.
Lay it out, play along with a you tube by the artist, make corrections (almost always), look for a you tube bass cover of the same, etc.
The tough thing is, we need to support the pay for tab sites too. Recording artists and songwriters depend upon protecting and being paid fairly for their intellectual property (their songs) to be able to continue doing so. I am a member of both BMI and ASCAP and believe strongly that we owe the guys that put the food on our cover band plates when asked to.
If you were in their shoes, you would see being a good guy and not charging for it only screws you the guy who created it. And for every Jon Bon Jovi, there is the Pastorius family. Jaco pissed everything away so many times, he died a broke fool. Nothing left to his heirs. His entire career basically for naught when considering the future of his loved ones. Although yes they are making some money from his estate, but it's not putting anybody in private schools money.
For the thousands of guys who can't afford it, and want to learn the music, I hear ya, it's tough, I washed dishes for my guitars once, I bused tables for amps, I cleaned the video booths at the adult arca....well never mind that.
For the thousands of us who actually get quick arrangements on the fly for being in a band that is getting paid for playing the songwriter's music, we darned well should be willing to pay something if required. I've never used online tabs to learn note for note stuff except for some signature licks I didn't want to spend time on.
I do agree it would be nice if they were always right, some are...most aren't. I keep using Ultimate-Guitar because it gets me in the ballpark quickly and then I mod the song as I work my way through it. I play nice big fat cover gigs and do get paid big fat cash, and I wouldn't have a problem paying should UG require that. But then again, I can spend an extra half hour charting it out from scratch like I do when i have to learn material not on UG. So while I would, I don't have to, so I might or I might not pay for it. But then again UG is free to use. And I do use it.
I do miss the old peer to peer sites. I do see the other side of the coin, you're actually helping to keep Alvin Lee remembered and honored when you download the tab to Goin' Home, or helping to keep alive that killer solo by Neil Geraldo on Pat Benetar's Heartbreaker or Leslie West's (RIP) ripping solo in Nantucket Sleighride. And for that tribute, I agree the fees should be more like 3 or 4 for $1 or something. But you should at least be able to look the arrangement over before paying to make sure it's not crap.