I have been tumbling between the Fender jaguar and the Ibanez ATK for a 4 string guitar that is not too expensive. Which one would you choose. It seems they both could be versatile. So, which one would you choose.
Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Which would be your preference?
- Thread starter subopposite
- Start date
I had the jaguar and it was fine once I replaced the pickups, shielded the body, and tweaked the electronics, which were noisey. I have the ATK700 in natural and it is a fine instrument and virtually maintenance free. They're not much for resale, and are available pretty cheap; I know, because I bought mine back once I sold it--gladly paying more.
If you like the Music Man vibe, the new Sterling By Musicman basses are nice. The ATK has a similar feel/character... but it's slightly different.
I'd decide based on which you prefer sound and feel wise...
I'd decide based on which you prefer sound and feel wise...
+1 just got a Peavey Grind 4 to convert to a fretless, it really is astonishing for the price. NT with good woods, nice finish, good setup and very playable electronics...cannot find a thing to fault.
I have the Jaguar, and I've played the ATK several times. My choice if definately the ATK. Though I must say, why these two? They have quite different sound, and the necks are complete opposites. For something else in the same range, I'd recommend an ibanez sr500 or higher, great electronics, and a slim fast neck.
Just think about what kind of sound you want, if you find it in the ATK, you're likely not to find it in the Jaguar.
Just think about what kind of sound you want, if you find it in the ATK, you're likely not to find it in the Jaguar.
I'm not an Ibby fan - and i think Jags are cool. Even knowing it needs tweaking, I'd go that route....OR more likely get an Eastwood Classic 4 hollowbody for $399.
$500-600 range can get you some nice basses especially if you look around used.
What kind of tone or vibe are you going for?
What kind of tone or vibe are you going for?
Between those two Id pick the Ibanez. But would be more inclined to get a Ibanez SR series instead. Just personal pref though.
I have to say if I was looking for a bass in that $$ range a rock bass would be a serious contender. played one at a local GC a month or so ago and it was really nice. passive too! (happen to like passive basses)
in the end I'm a P guy so that would weigh highly in the mix too ...
If you've never owned a Jaguar, you should get one (just to say you played a Jag). Yes, it's different, yes it probably isn't as sophisticated as some of the others mentioned, and yes it can get some getting used to, but my god, the different tone variations and and sounds you can get from it are awesome! And its looks always gets comments from the audience (girls love it....it just looks friggin cool!) It's like owning a Masarati.....not a terrific car, but the effect it has is worth the effort!! If your into everyday, boring, run of the mill basses, by all means get an Ibanez, Peavey, or Fender J or P, but if your if you want to make a statement..........
