• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Why Do We Join The Wrong Bands

I don't feel bad for you, Blue. You made your choices, and you seem perfectly content with them. Plus, you often post up interesting and thought-provoking questions such as the one that started this thread. If music is what you do, and what you choose, and what you are, then to deny that which makes us what we are is the only real thing to feel sad about.

Music is secondary to me, but it has a special place in my life. Sure, I might be the "Resident Hack", but honestly I've been involved in music, in some form, for most of my life. Bass guitar is my most recent focus after woodwinds, piano, percussion, and guitar. Honestly, bass guitar is my favorite of all of them.

But my hobbies and interests are varied. Motorcycles, cars (I currently have a great fun car I bought), movies, etc..., but most importantly my family. I would pitch everything and anything for them, especially my son.

You see, here is where music has been a gift from God in my life.

My son Daniel is 11 years old and a wonderful, loving boy who wants to grow up to be an auto mechanic. He loves dogs, thinks fettucini alfredo is the best food ever, and watches super hero movies. Batman is his favorite.

Daniel is also autistic. On the milder side of the spectrum, but was quickly identified at a young age.

When he was 8 years old I put a guitar in his hands. He watched me play a few instruments and he just seemed to "understand" music. The guitar came naturally to him, he was easily able to navigate his way through the strings, and he somehow just adapted to it. He had a keen sense for what sounded right, what sounded wrong, and how to make that guitar say what he wanted it to. He idolizes Slash, and he is currently the lead guitarist in the Jazz Band at the school he attends. For his birthday we got him a flame top Les Paul similar to Slash's guitar from Appetite For Destruction.

Music allowed me to make a connection with my son and share a commonality that I was struggling with. When he sees our band perform he lights up and I see the boy that is inside him that most of the world doesn't see. The other band members have adopted him as a "junior member" and they let him sing sometimes or play guitar with our songs in practice. The kid is so good he showed our lead player a couple things he figured out on songs we do.

So for me, music is a hobby but also a life enhancing feature, if you can call it that. While others talk about how much money they are getting, or whether their bands are successful, or what amp to buy, I'm really thankful when I sit down with my son and play basslines so he can practice his upcoming guitar solo for the school concert. The rest of it....well, it doesn't mean much. Sure, I make a couple bucks playing for a mediocre cover band in dive bars with a bunch of drunks belting out "Friends In Low Places" (which I sing), but my real happiness comes from watching an 11 year old boy smile and say "Thanks, Dad. I needed some help on my solo. Mr. K-M is going to like it".
 
So for me, music is a hobby but also a life enhancing feature, if you can call it that. While others talk about how much money they are getting, or whether their bands are successful, or what amp to buy, I'm really thankful when I sit down with my son and play basslines so he can practice his upcoming guitar solo for the school concert. The rest of it....well, it doesn't mean much. Sure, I make a couple bucks playing for a mediocre cover band in dive bars with a bunch of drunks belting out "Friends In Low Places" (which I sing), but my real happiness comes from watching an 11 year old boy smile and say "Thanks, Dad. I needed some help on my solo. Mr. K-M is going to like it".

As a father, the guardian of an autistic brother, and a lover of music - I totally LOVE this story.

I really believe in music being a powerful thing. To reduce it to just selling booze and making boobies bounce, really diminishes what it can actually do. Not that there's anything wrong with booze or boobies. Actually, there's lots of right things with them, but music can accomplish much more than that.

If you measure music solely by how much money you make, how often you gig, how many people you draw, how many CDs you sell, how many scales you know, etc., it can cause you to lose sight of how powerful music can be. The thing with you and your son, how can it be measured? It can't, because it's just too great.
 
Thanks, Jive. A week or so ago he did really well. He's a big fan of the music we play and he decided I should play my bass along with him while he played guitar and sang Eric Church's song "Homeboy" (he really likes that one, it's drop-tuned so he thinks it's cool). I sang it with him and I really had to work to hold back the tears while I watched him playing and singing.

I sang along with him. I sing the Eric Church songs we do.

For those of you who don't know it, or never think of it, music is a powerful thing. It makes me laugh, cry, and puts me in a place that nothing else could.

Don't reduce it to money. Or notoriety. Or status. Just remember, you get to DO THIS. Not everyone does. Give your music the respect and reverence it deserves.
 
BayStateBass said:
I don't feel bad for you, Blue. You made your choices, and you seem perfectly content with them. Plus, you often post up interesting and thought-provoking questions such as the one that started this thread. If music is what you do, and what you choose, and what you are, then to deny that which makes us what we are is the only real thing to feel sad about.

You see, here is where music has been a gift from God in my life.

Thanks,

I'm a relic to most tbers. Yes, I'm happy and excited about what I'm doing and things I want to do at the local level.

However, I like reading about what other tbers are doing the good things, the struggles and the hassles.

Blue
 
Thanks,

I'm a relic to most tbers. Yes, I'm happy and excited about what I'm doing and things I want to do at the local level.

However, I like reading about what other tbers are doing the good things, the struggles and the hassles.

Blue

You're not a relic to me, but an "old soul".

I've found that older players are a goldmine of information and experience. Nothing replaces experience. Personally, I choose to associate with experienced players because the information is priceless.

Now here I am, almost 40. And my music is better than ever. I imagine at 60 I will be able to look back and see the folly of my 40's and laugh.

If you're doing what you love and it makes you happy, then you're far ahead of a lot of others who are still living in the life others told them they should have.
 
Thanks, Jive. A week or so ago he did really well. He's a big fan of the music we play and he decided I should play my bass along with him while he played guitar and sang Eric Church's song "Homeboy" (he really likes that one, it's drop-tuned so he thinks it's cool). I sang it with him and I really had to work to hold back the tears while I watched him playing and singing.

I sang along with him. I sing the Eric Church songs we do.

For those of you who don't know it, or never think of it, music is a powerful thing. It makes me laugh, cry, and puts me in a place that nothing else could.

Don't reduce it to money. Or notoriety. Or status. Just remember, you get to DO THIS. Not everyone does. Give your music the respect and reverence it deserves.

Awesome story! My music has only helped my bond with my Daughter. She is only 8 but music is a big part of her life. She is a good singer and is starting to learn guitar from me. Since she was 5 she has gone to practices and gigs even sat for a show on my bass amp at a Farmers market we played once singing all my bands songs :D I play guitar while she sings songs she likes today.

The bond we make with our children thru music is priceless and something they will hopefully carry and remember long after we are gone.
 
Hell, it might have been the right band, but then changed...

or more-specifically, appeared to be the right band...

or more-specifically, one or two in the band wanted to change the direction of the band at the last minute...

or more specifically, from the beginning they intended to change the direction of the band, but waited for the last minute, then threaten to quit if it didn't change so it would be difficult for the others to abandon all they'd invested...

or more specifically, they wanted a second guitarist in order to turn a variety band into a Rock band...

Okay, this happened some years ago, old drama. :D



Btw... I kinda miss (the OP) Bluewine . :cigar:
.
 
Last edited:
For me, the reason I've joined wrong bands has predominantly been out of boredom, not doing anything musically, just want to play music or someone rings up and asks me to come along.

I'm at a stage now where I'd rather not be playing than being in a band I don't want to be in.
I just dont need the hassle.

Sometimes you just don't know it's the wrong band until hidden ego's are unbridled and open for all to see.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Marko 1
Assuming you've done due diligence then you wont join the wrong band but there are plenty of things that go wrong down the line.
Last case in point..we had all the 'right' components bar the drummer.
It was definitely a BL thing ..only nobody decreed this was the model.
Anyway, they found a drummer which was mistake number 1. He was technically great but it emboldened assumed BL to adopt the BL role.
Drummer brought quite a swagger with him.
However,
Musically all there, but I told them it wasn't working on day one when we met to top tail the set.

Had a very successful 1st year but the two sensible ones left and the BL...who I'm sure pulls the same musical trick everywhere.. has disappeared into solo work.
Just because you sing lead and bring the material, mostly, does not make you a BL with any respect.
The day I met him and heard a great vox was the day I couldn't put my finger on what was wrong with him but i know there was something.
And so it transpired.
Total idiot.