• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Why is Bass underestimated?

Basses are mostly in lower frequency unless you go high on the highest string or unless it's bass only. Even if it's bass only or high pitch, the frequency is much lower than 1khz (vocals) and a bit harder to hear out all the details that is below 750hz basically. These lower frequencies are sensed in deeper part of cochlea. Guitars, drums (except bass drums and some production puts Toms in lower frequency. Triggered Bass Drum are definitely well above 750hz though), and vocals are usually above 750hz (Some bands use 8-string guitars which is usually downtuned and uses bass string in the lowest so it may go lower). They are much easier to hear and mostly sensed closer to the entrance of cochlea.
If you listen to Jazz, you can easily hear what they are playing, but in Pop, Rock, Punk and especially in Metal, guitars sound covers up all the bass sounds. Especially in Metal, where guitar use heavy distortion and bass drums are triggered, it's very hard to hear the bass (especially when Drums are doing Blast Beats). if you compare Rock and Metal, you will easily understand that bass are way harder to hear in Metal. Take the Death Metal Band, NILE for example. Despite the bassline being the same technical line the guitarists are playing, if you are careless, you can't even hear the great techniques being played behind the guitars, fast blast beats on drums, and death vocals.

Now how about Jazz? Or any band that has bass solos? Yes of course, bass is amazing when it comes to solo. You can't really do slap bass on guitar unless you have a pencil-like finger that can go through narrow space between the strings. There are bassist who use picks and bassist who use fingers. Using pick will make the sound sharper, thus making them able to hear, but it's somewhat less impressive than guitar because for physical reasons (Bass guitar has larger gaps between strings and the strings are thicker which makes it harder for speed picking. Also, most common bass is 4 string, which limits the available notes unlike guitars which commonly has 6 strings). Finger playing unfortunately does not make sharp sound but rather rounded smooth sounds. This means harder to hear because the sound is somewhat muffled. That means even if you do an unbelievable fingerwork, the muffling will end up making it harder to hear in solos. Take Blood Red Throne in song called "Slaying the Lamb". Around latter half, there is a solo which does finger-sweeping, but you can't really hear it so much even if it's accurate and way far from sloppy (sloppy solos are harder to hear). Slap bass, in that case is the better option to make them hear out, but slap bass are much more like a percussion-ish lines and despite being extremely difficult and technical, it sounds nothing more than a simple basslines with additional percussion in the background, when it's not; as a result it sounds like a rhythmic line rather than a flashy solo that stands out.

Bass also physically "looks" like an easier version of guitar. Most basses are 4 string while guitar is 6 string. Of course bassist in Viraemia has 10-string bass, and bassist in Brain Drill owning 7-string bass, and bassist in Necrophagist having 6-string, bassist in Cannibal Corpse and Origin having 5-string. But usually it's 4. Also there are plenty of unorthodox Electric Guitar shapes like V and V2s, Random Star, Warlock, Firebird, etc. You can also make one for bass, but they don't really look so good (I find Warlock Basses cool though).


Summary
Basses are underestimated for several reasons:
1) Biomechanical Aspect - the cochlea and frequencies
2) Technical Aspect - Being compared; bass having rounder "muffled" sound as opposed to guitars having sharper "cleaner" sound. Bass also has limited note range.
3) Physical Aspect - Types of shapes available that actually looks good (or crazy). Also the numbers of strings.



Of course you know that a band without a bass sound like bogus. With bass and without bass make HUGE HUGE HUGE HUGE difference in a band. Actually, bass is more commonly used than guitar in pop and jazz. Unfortunately, many people take bass as necessary "back-ups".
 
I don't run across people who think bass is underestimated, but rather other players (guitarist's, drummer's, etc.) who don't like taking suggestions from me, a bass player who also happens to play guitar and who can write his own songs with lyrics.

I've really noticed this at the practice sessions at the church where I play bass at. We'll be going over a song and if it's not going right I'll say (and very nicely) "instead of that, why don't we try this because it will work better." Can't belive the resistance I get from all. But when I take a stand and make suggestions it's only when I know I'm right. Believe me, I'm not at all pushy about it and they won't budge. So we play it wrong.

You folks ever run into this problem? Getting flack from others because of that old mindset? "What do YOU know?"
 
THIS!

scrolldown.jpg

...most pple cant hear it cause they dont know what they are listening for...

I have met VERY, VERY few musicians who understand or practice critical listening (except maybe to their own instrument). I'm pretty sure I have met NO non-musicians who know what critical listening is or how to do it at all. They don't even understand what the heck "critical listening" means.
 
The White Stripes? The Doors? Death From Above 1979? Metallica?
The Doors used an organ for bass. White Stripes use a Invalid Link Removed and it's reasonable to think that they could also record an electric bass in the studio (I'm sure Jack White can play one). No bass in Metallica? What?

What blows my mind is why no one ever uses this as an example of music with no bass. Now, THAT'S music with no bass.

Mainstream music pretty much always has a bass line. It just might not get played on an electric bass/bass "guitar".
 
It think that this post has been misread/ misunderstood.

The OPs' question was about other people's perception of the instrument. Arguing that its actually really important and cool, is missing the point.

The public don't register that the bass exists because they are looking at the singer, the guitarist, and the crazy drummer - in that order. I once put my bass down and walked off stage in the interval. I got 10 feet before someone asked me:- "what did I think of the band?".

If we were in the building industry, ask yourself who gets the attention. The guy who makes foundations or the guy who fits the roof?

Maybe the other reason is that is really hard to hold the groove AND play a solo. If you stop to play a solo, the groove stops and the music becomes .....less.

Agreed,that is exactly my experience of "how other people" (which to me that means joe average punter),perceive a bass guitarist.

I have had tons of instances over 20 odd years,playing onstage for 3 hours (3 piece + vocals) , where I am a nobody,cant even get back in the venue after ciggy break outside because of my shoes ! and then trying to convince them I am in the "band", :eyebrow:

Hit a mistake on the bass during a song and its "dog balls" to all...no matter what the perception.
 

Latest posts