It’s just regular stuff from the grocery store, but I would guess there are lots of factors influencing how fast it goes. Ratio of steel wool to vinegar, temperature, fineness of the steel wool, how tightly it’s packed, whether it’s been oiled to stop it rusting, etc. It could also be that I have a piece of especially tannin-y walnut. I applied the same dye to a scrap of oak and it turned a fairly light brown.That was fast! It took my vinegaroon dye a couple weeks to reach full strength. Maybe you had stronger vinegar.
What Slidlow said. I don’t think I ever heard the word vinegaroon before 1n3 mentioned it, but it does seem to be fairly common. And it’s a totally ludicrous word, which I love.What's vinegaroon?
I lightly sanded it with 150 grit paper to smooth it out again and lost very little of the colour. Gave it one more shot of dye just because, but I think it’s good to go.

