• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Wondering how to deal with this problem...

Our guitarist owns the entire PA and we're constantly fighting over sound. I'm the only wireless player, so during sound check I like to run out front by the sound guy and listen to the mix and notice the same problems we have in practice, as well.

So, here's the problem - the mix is simply awful! The guitarist and sound guy don't seem to get it, and it's definitely a sore spot for me.

First, the drums are always too loud...usually the loudest part of the mix. The bass is often times the quietest, at least in terms of cutting power, if not overall volume. The keys stomp all over the bass, as our keyboardist is a "solo" type player, loving the low end, as if there was no bass player (and I'm a busy player), and since he's so loud, he trounces all over my tone. The rest of the band is generally adequately mixed.

More specifically, with my tone, is that the low end is excessively thick in the lows and the upper mids (a frequency I'm not terribly fond of to begin with) don't cut through, regardless of how I set my eq on both my preamp (an Avalon VT-737sp) AND on the board. On the Avalon, for the most recent show, I employed the high-pass filter so the lows wouldn't be so boomy, but found the volume wasn't there. To offset this, the sound guy cranked the treble on the bass channel on the board all the way up, so at least it was noticeable, but there was no fundamental in my playing - only attack. The lows were on the poor side of adequate, but compared to how they were before the high-pass filter was engaged, it was an improvement.

I've tried numerous eq settings on my Avalon, and as you might expect, it's got a tremendous eq...but for some reason it just doesn't quite cut the mustard once the full band is going. It's really odd! One such setting I've got is cranking the treble and mids (around 400 Hz and either 800 Hz or 2kHz) while cutting the lows. The recording of our last show had no bass, whatsoever!

And, while this may or may not be a factor, there's one other thing I want to mention...IMO the subs are too powerful and the mains are too small, so we don't get a good balance...I'm just wondering if that could, in fact, be a factor. I can tell you the crossover is set at about 94 Hz with a pretty steep slope, but anything we've tried higher than that as a crossover point gets distorted and muddy sounding. The 94 Hz was the highest we could go without adding muddy distortion. However, on tape (this same show was recorded), the only bass comes out as attack with no fundamental, much as I mentioned before. It seems that the subs produce low end that's simply not being recorded...don't know if that's normal or a sign of something going awry.

My headphone mix is perfect, and the bass sounds tremendous through my headphones, but absolutely lost through the mains. UGH!

Again, in this situation, I'm pretty limited, as far as influence goes, because the guitarist who owns the entire PA is also, at the end of the day, a guitarist, and mixes as if he's a guitarist.

I'm really curious as to how to get a better tone.

Any thoughts? Is the information I provided even good enough to KIND OF make sense?
 
what kind of music is it? do you have any examples? You should talk to the keyboard player about the lows, he is being rude. For cutting through more, try low mids around 200-400 hz and high mids around 1k hz. Don't crank anything, just cut freq you don't want. Treble about 1.5k-2k will tend to give a thin or sharp tone, so I roll them off and I slightly roll of lows below 100 hz to cut mud and give the kick drum room.

Of course it depends heavily on what speakers you guys are using, and what bass and the style of music.
 
You should talk to the keyboard player about the lows, he is being rude.
+1 - I was playing B3 on a blues/rock gig w/girl bass player (good player too). I had been playing solo for so long I was being an ignorant t*rd and was playing some left hand bass. She cranked that GK800 up and kicked my *ss with dBs. The OP might consider doing the same. What is that old saying - something like... "If you can't persuade them with your reason, then crush them with your weight."

But the OP's posting is really about how he can have a say-so in the FOH sound. Given the situation the OP described, I would not be optimistic about having any influence in that area. All you can do is try to voice your concerns. Give it a shot - the live recordings might help. Let them know you are just trying to get the best sound for the band that is possible.
 
I've thought that, but the guys are too important to me...

I hope you're not letting misplaced loyalty diminish your opportunities to advance. Also, you could become assistant FOH, just an idea. Keep using the live recordings for evidence.

what kind of music is it? do you have any examples? You should talk to the keyboard player about the lows, he is being rude. ...

Might not be rude, just not accustomed to playing with bassists. This sounds a lot like a church setting. One way to cope is to play less on bass, choosing only blank spots that highlight the melody's chords - this is what I had to do when I first started, since the keyboardist was accustomed to playing everything at once.

Of course it depends heavily on what speakers you guys are using, and what bass and the style of music.
True that. In addition, I suggest using a direct box to FOH, let your system fill out the stage sound.
 
I had an interesting discussion with the guitarist tonight about it all. The problem with our keyboardist is that he's got very little time to practice outside of practice. He's the reason we're all together and owns the space where we rehearse, plus he's close friends with all of us...talk about job security!

Anyway, from the guitarists mouth, "I've threatened to cut off his left hand on numerous occasions!" He went on to say it's one of the shortcomings we have to learn to live with in this band (not the answer I'd like to hear, of course).

The keyboardist is truly incapable of playing keyboard lines that support the music, but rather he tends to duplicate what the guitarist plays, but on piano. And, he does so in a way he probably learned when he took lessons as a pre-teen, as I'd imagine learning on an upright piano reading charts with a teacher, learning how to play all the parts of a song as they're written in most early-learning lesson books. It's not as if he could play a horn line with his synth where it'd fit nicely, but rather he outlines chords and plays the bass line on the keys simultaneously.

One example is Sweet Caroline by Neil Diamond (you'd be surprised how the ladies in the audience go NUTS when they hear this song, regardless of how bad we make it sound, lol). I listened to our recording from the other night and then the original version. Jeff (our keyboardist) plays NOTHING even REMOTELY close to the actual keyboard line OR the horn line (and believe me, he's got the sounds built into his board). Instead, he plays a piano part that's probably written in any entry-level song book for a beginning piano student.

I have a 14 gig file (15 raw tracks) from a recent practice that I need to mix on my computer using Pro-Tools (I'm far from an expert, believe me) that I'm going to give to our guitarist when I get it sounding good. Hopefully we can use that as a sonic template going forward. I don't have very high hopes.:rollno:

Still, anything I CAN do to make MY sound better is more than welcome. Bigblondeafro's suggestion at boosting around 400 Hz, etc, will be on the top of my list as things to try when we get together again later this week.

Any other suggestions? Thanks so much for your advice!
 
Still, anything I CAN do to make MY sound better is more than welcome. Bigblondeafro's suggestion at boosting around 400 Hz, etc, will be on the top of my list as things to try when we get together again later this week.

Any other suggestions? Thanks so much for your advice!

From all your descriptions (including sound tech boosting treble to get bass heard), the best I can think of in that situation is to take the numerous hints, actually disconnect yourself from FOH, & mix bass in with your rig. What's the worst that could happen if you do that: the mix will sound lousy? That's where you are now. I'm not really serious on that recommendation, but desperate times etc.

Best way to fix a problem is at the source, & it seems like that's mainly Keys & Sound. But if friendship is so overriding musicianship in this band, the full problem might be a lot broader. It might be time for a hard decision.
 
BTW, I always find that when the low end is crowded, I've got to simplify my pulse. Gotta be the kind of player the situation calls for.
I wish that would work for us, but the truth is, without sounding cocky, I'm a big part of our sound. The guitarist is okay, and the keyboardist kinda isn't so talented. I fill up a lot of sonic space.

I definitely play what's called for and wish that were the answer. In fact, there are some really simple lines I play that get completely buried because the keyboardist has a horrible sense of things. Since we're a cover band, I'd appreciate it if he'd play the song as it were written, or in songs where there are no keys in the original, at least play something supporting "what's called for".

This band situation is such that these guys have almost literally saved me from myself, and I mean that in the most sincere ways. My devotion to them is more important than finding a new band or replacing any of the members at this point in my life. I'd rather find a way to HAPPILY fit my tone in with them rather than get buried in the mix. It's a problematic situation.

Thanks for the advice, though.
 
sneak over to the board, flatten your channel and kill the lows on the keyboard channel when no-one's looking. if it sounds good for the song or two you might get before it gets changed, insist on it next show.
 
How about asking the keyboard player again? Why won't he listen? Ask him?

Maybe tape his right hand up with tape? Or glue all his lower register keys together.

Since the keyboard player doesn't have time to practice on his own, he's really not carrying his weight other than the rehearsal space.

Since they're not worried about FOH sound, what's under your control? I say bring in a 1k watt bass stack and blast them at rehearsal. When they ask you to turn down, ask them why you should listen to them when they don't listen to you?

Then you say you'll turn down because you want the entire band to sound good and they should do what's necessary as well. If they don't, oh well. Enjoy your monitor mix and don't worry about it. Collect your paycheck and have fun. That's what your other band members are doing.
 
Others may disagree but I would suggest this for EQ settings when you're fighting with the keyboard player.


Low bass - cut below 60 Hz, boost at 100 Hz

Mid bass - cut (a lot) between 300 - 600 Hz

Mids - boost (a lot) between 2,500 Hz and 3,500 Hz

Highs - cut everything above 5,000 Hz


These settings will make your bass quieter in the mix and your sound man will then turn the bass channel up in the mains. When he does, your bass will magically cut through in frequencies that are not filled up by keys and guitars, particularly at 100 Hz and 3,000 Hz which you cleverly boosted. ;)

I do this all the time with live sound and it works particularly well with subwoofers.
 
...He went on to say it's one of the shortcomings we have to learn to live with in this band (not the answer I'd like to hear, of course).

The keyboardist is truly incapable of playing keyboard lines that support the music, but rather he tends to duplicate what the guitarist plays, but on piano....Any other suggestions? Thanks so much for your advice!
-1 million SUPER LAME!
I used to play keyboards in a band. I took piano lessons. We are taught to play the whole song ourselves on the piano. I didn't do that in the band...WHY?
Because I was able to LEARN the RIGHT WAY to play in a band. Why is this one of the shortcomings that YOU have learn to live with? Why can't the keyboardist learn how to play correctly within a band?
Sounds like either the keyboard player is lazy or arrogant or (more likely) none of you guys have the nutties to tell him what he's doing wrong.

I doubt the keyboardist is "incapable" of learning the right lines...if he is, then he's no musician. My "sergeant's nose" is smelling fear. It's not that he can't learn what he needs to; it's that you guys are afraid to corner him on it and let him know what needs to be done.

In a band setting, the keyboard is a SUPPORT instrument, not a lead instrument (unless you're Elton John). Your keys guy needs to learn to stay in his lane...period.

In the end, it sounds like it's more important to you to play with your friends than anything else. So, maybe you should just realize that you've chosen a compromise for yourself and just live with it. It's no big deal. When you're ready to be serious about your art, you'll find a way to get with the right people.

What can you do to improve YOUR sound? I don't know. Probaby not much. What's the point anyway? It appears like the whole band sounds like crap anyway. So your sound is better; your sound is worse...who cares? Does it really matter? I doubt it.

IMO, more important than trying to fix the sound of this situation is learning how to handle conflict and learning how to give & take constructive criticism. You had a talk with the guitarist but he's not the problem; the keyboardist is. Why is no one ready to talk to the keyboardist? :eyebrow:

I know you said your a 'big part of the sound'...but it seems like you may be the only one in the band who thinks so. The others are walking all over your sound and you're being mixed OUT of the sound (from what you've indicated). I'm guessing that they don't even HEAR you and don't realize that they can't hear you. Sorry to break your balls but I really think that everyone in that band is only listening to themselves play...you're the only one listening to you; and CLEARLY the soundman isn't listening to you! Sounds like the soundman could stand to read a book about sound mixing too.

Sorry for being so harsh...but it just seems to me that your situation sucks and it doesn't NEED TO. All it takes is some back bone to stand up and explain some things to people.

Good Luck with it.
 
As an Amazon Associate, TalkBass may receive commissions from qualifying purchases made via links on this site.
IMO the subs are too powerful and the mains are too small, so we don't get a good balance...

Not that this will make you feel any better, but in a lot of bands that own their own P.A., the reverse is true. I.e., they skimp on the subs (and the wattage to power them) and you wind up with not enough bottom end and the bass guitar sounding like a ukelele and/or the bassist having to crank his rig onstage to make up for weak P.A.

Sounds like you're in a tough situation... it can be tricky when one band member owns most or all of the P.A.
 
Others may disagree but I would suggest this for EQ settings when you're fighting with the keyboard player.


Low bass - cut below 60 Hz, boost at 100 Hz

Mid bass - cut (a lot) between 300 - 600 Hz

Mids - boost (a lot) between 2,500 Hz and 3,500 Hz

Highs - cut everything above 5,000 Hz


These settings will make your bass quieter in the mix and your sound man will then turn the bass channel up in the mains. When he does, your bass will magically cut through in frequencies that are not filled up by keys and guitars, particularly at 100 Hz and 3,000 Hz which you cleverly boosted. ;)

I do this all the time with live sound and it works particularly well with subwoofers.

Good advice, assuming that the OP's bass cab is being mic'd, or the board is getting a DI feed Post-amp EQ. If neither of these is true, then the OP can tweak his amp EQ till next Tuesday and the effect on his sound in the house will be negligible.
 
Since they're not worried about FOH sound, what's under your control? I say bring in a 1k watt bass stack and blast them at rehearsal. When they ask you to turn down, ask them why you should listen to them when they don't listen to you?

Then you say you'll turn down because you want the entire band to sound good and they should do what's necessary as well. If they don't, oh well. Enjoy your monitor mix and don't worry about it. Collect your paycheck and have fun. That's what your other band members are doing.
LOL...my full rig already has a Stewart World 2.1, and I was running it bridged mono (up to 1,800 watts) into a 4-ohm Epifani 4x10 UL. That's one of the big reasons we ended up with the IEM setup - because I'm always "the loud one" when I have ANY control.
 
-1 million SUPER LAME!
I used to play keyboards in a band. I took piano lessons. We are taught to play the whole song ourselves on the piano. I didn't do that in the band...WHY?
Because I was able to LEARN the RIGHT WAY to play in a band. Why is this one of the shortcomings that YOU have learn to live with? Why can't the keyboardist learn how to play correctly within a band?
Sounds like either the keyboard player is lazy or arrogant or (more likely) none of you guys have the nutties to tell him what he's doing wrong.

I doubt the keyboardist is "incapable" of learning the right lines...if he is, then he's no musician. My "sergeant's nose" is smelling fear. It's not that he can't learn what he needs to; it's that you guys are afraid to corner him on it and let him know what needs to be done.

In a band setting, the keyboard is a SUPPORT instrument, not a lead instrument (unless you're Elton John). Your keys guy needs to learn to stay in his lane...period.

In the end, it sounds like it's more important to you to play with your friends than anything else. So, maybe you should just realize that you've chosen a compromise for yourself and just live with it. It's no big deal. When you're ready to be serious about your art, you'll find a way to get with the right people.

What can you do to improve YOUR sound? I don't know. Probaby not much. What's the point anyway? It appears like the whole band sounds like crap anyway. So your sound is better; your sound is worse...who cares? Does it really matter? I doubt it.

IMO, more important than trying to fix the sound of this situation is learning how to handle conflict and learning how to give & take constructive criticism. You had a talk with the guitarist but he's not the problem; the keyboardist is. Why is no one ready to talk to the keyboardist? :eyebrow:

I know you said your a 'big part of the sound'...but it seems like you may be the only one in the band who thinks so. The others are walking all over your sound and you're being mixed OUT of the sound (from what you've indicated). I'm guessing that they don't even HEAR you and don't realize that they can't hear you. Sorry to break your balls but I really think that everyone in that band is only listening to themselves play...you're the only one listening to you; and CLEARLY the soundman isn't listening to you! Sounds like the soundman could stand to read a book about sound mixing too.

Sorry for being so harsh...but it just seems to me that your situation sucks and it doesn't NEED TO. All it takes is some back bone to stand up and explain some things to people.

Good Luck with it.

Okay, so to be clear, it seems you actually understand and can more eloquently relate what I was trying to say about this guy! :D

Yes...superlame! It frustrates the living crap out of me!
 
As an Amazon Associate, TalkBass may receive commissions from qualifying purchases made via links on this site.
Others may disagree but I would suggest this for EQ settings when you're fighting with the keyboard player.


Low bass - cut below 60 Hz, boost at 100 Hz

Mid bass - cut (a lot) between 300 - 600 Hz

Mids - boost (a lot) between 2,500 Hz and 3,500 Hz

Highs - cut everything above 5,000 Hz


These settings will make your bass quieter in the mix and your sound man will then turn the bass channel up in the mains. When he does, your bass will magically cut through in frequencies that are not filled up by keys and guitars, particularly at 100 Hz and 3,000 Hz which you cleverly boosted. ;)

I do this all the time with live sound and it works particularly well with subwoofers.
That's some advice I think I'm going to use...we'll see if it gets us anywhere.

The only problem with using IEMs is I've got a great mix in my own head with ZERO keyboards! Afterall, I don't need them.