• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Wood type based on 1 picture?

Most people don't realize Philippine Mahogany isn't a mahogany at all. It's a tropical red cedar. I learned this during my boat building days.

Yep, I realize that. I'm just going by what we used to buy here in So Cal lumberyards that was labeled Philippine Mahogany. I've built maybe a dozen bass bodies from it.
 
As @Beej already mentioned, basswood is much plainer than what is seen here. Basswood is a popular carving wood based, in part, on how little it shows of itself. It makes a pretty good lightweight body under a hard finish, so long as the hard finish isn't struck too hard.
 
Pores look like just like luaun. That's one of dozens of varieties of woods in the Meranti family. Some like your example are whiter than luaun. Meranti is a low cost, plentiful Asian hardwood, not necessarily lousy wood, but I avoid Meranti species--coarse and splintery, not especially stiff compared to weight, not super stable like real mahogany and the only wood that ever sent me to the Emergency Room(!)

White Meranti | The Wood Database (Hardwood)
Balau | The Wood Database (Hardwood)

In the 70s (showing my age here) I was carrying a particle board exterior door through an apartment building construction site and slipping between piles of stuff. The splintery edge of a piece of luaun plywood put a 1 1/4" splinter into my thigh as I was walking past that broke off under the skin. I couldn't get it out. It wasn't deep, went in crosswise. In the ER it took one tiny injection, one tiny incision and one or two tiny stitches and all gone.

In 2024 would have cost over 3k, but back then, not a big deal financially at all.

Anyway I already didn't like working with it. But as a body I'm sure it's fine. Looking at the stiffness, maple is in the 12s, walnut in the 11s and meranti is in the 10s, so I wouldn't make a neck out of it, but a body, sure. Sorry, TMI.
My Indonesian made Sterling short scale
was made from the same stuff, whatever it may be. I am judging by the neck pocket. It is a splintery wood.
 
Hello dear wood informed folks!

View attachment 5443908

What wood do you think that is, based on the grain on that picture?
Thank you for your help
That is certainly Agathis, no question.

(BTW Anyone who said this looks like alder has just had their wood identification privileges revoked. You’re still allowed in the “I don’t believe in tonewood” threads though lol. I don’t make the rules.)
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: DJ Bebop
That is certainly Agathis, no question.

(BTW Anyone who said this looks like alder has just had their wood identification privileges revoked. You’re still allowed in the “I don’t believe in tonewood” threads though lol. I don’t make the rules.)

Certainly, but still lots of different points of view...
Let's all say it's not plywood!!

Have a nice weekend:cool:
 
  • Like
Reactions: DJ Bebop
If I had to vote/bet I’d go with agathis, but I really don’t have a clue, so…

Alright, nevermind! There's no definitive answer to be given. This body was from 2010 and Fender stated it was Alder back then but subject to change. They used Agathis as far as I know but oh well... I think I'm gonna sell it "as is". Thank you for your inputs

that’s your answer… it’s simply a 2010 Squier body. No other info needed, any guess would potentially deceive the buyer.