• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join free Log in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Double Bass Worlds Longest Bass Solo attempt

#21
Don Kasper said:
Hi Matthew,
I am just judging the actual "performance" as a stand-alone piece, as an observer or receptor of "art". If the guy was raising money to cure Cancer, I would not like this stunt any better. I try and separate the "explanation" behind the art from the "art" itself - but that is me. (Tom Wolf's book "The Painted Word", explores this issue, that has become rampant in the visual Art World.) So, If Hitler had painted beautiful paintings, should our response to his art be tempered by his other horrible actions? I've spoken with former members of Ray Charles' band, who say he was a pretty nasty person. Should this diminish my opinion of his music? (I try not to think of his personal shortcomings when listening to his beautiful music.)
Yes - this type of improvised performance is not my "thing", but when someone presents a work of art to he world, I believe that there is an implicit agreement that the listener/viewer/observer will experience some sort of honest "reaction", positive/negative/(or a mix of both). I am just completing the transaction between artist and recipient, and, yes, I'm not always as polite as some people. (This is one of MY many "personal shortcomings", perhaps?!)
I've had my say, and maybe it's time I shut up...
Thank You for your time and civility. I appreciate both.
G'day, Mate?
Click to expand...

This is ridiculous even by your standards Don. Clayton is raising money to fund an arts festival - that is comparable to genocide in your book? You don't have to like his playing - although if you listened to a few random minutes of a 24 performance I'm not sure that'd equip you to judge - but he's doing something pretty impressive (as well as a really fun idea) and for a very good reason. For what it's worth I've met him and heard him a few times, think he's a fantastic bassist and a really nice bloke.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Matthew Tucker
#22
I am, however, on board with Don's discomfort with organized "stunt" donations. I truly hate it when my brother's kids hit me up for money for a runathon, walkathon, skiathon, etc. I don't mind paying to go into a music club or art museum to support something which I value, or donating to a charity. I gave Bernie Sanders a hundred bucks, and he certainly didn't offer to run ten miles or play bass for a whole day. And that in no way diminished my support for him. I'm not so sure about the whole *-athon approach, which sort of shames you into donating to a cause based upon someone you know doing something physically demanding which has little or nothing to do with the charity. If in this case it did bring in some funding, then I am fine with that. I'm just glad no one hit me up personally. That would have been uncomfortable, and conflicting with the concept of "choice".
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Don Kasper
#25
Don Kasper said:
No. I did not compare this guy to H. Please reread my post.
Thank You.
Click to expand...
I'm sure you didn't mean it that way, but you did bring up the name for comparison's sake immediately after an already negative and nasty reaction to this project. I've re-read your posts several times, and I've given up trying to understand your actual point. As far as I can tell, you just wanted to rain on somebody's parade.

I thought this was a very brave and successful project, stunt or not. I tuned in for a portion of it, and was pleasantly surprised by the quality of music and performance.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Matthew Tucker, damonsmith and oliebrice
#26
For comparison - Clayton is on 49 albums here:
Invalid Link Removed

vs.

"No results found for "don kasper" bass discogs."

Kenny Wheeler, Dave Holland and many others Don admires have worked in the 50 year old tradition of free improvisation. This area of music is not about anyone "enjoying" it in the traditional sense. I "enjoy" hearing new sounds & new forms, so that is what I get out of it. However, there are years and years of working on how to improvise in real time and those findings should be valuable to anyone who thinks they improvise.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Matthew Tucker
#28
Mingus was my hero in high school but I never got to hear him live. Finally got a chance in college, and loved it. Between sets I crossed his path going to the men's room. My chance to talk to him! Mr Mingus you've been a hero of mine for years. He replied shag YOU. Though I still loved the music, I didn't love it quite as much. Same exact music. I think that's the point about Hitler's painting, though his stolid student crap can't be compared to Mingus' great art.
 

Latest posts

Top Bottom
Back