I just re-read all 32 pages of this thread for the 5th or 6th time. I took notes so that I wouldn’t have to do it again. I love you guys, but man … there is ~2 pages of actual information about this pickup spread out over these 32 pages.
So, it sounds like we THINK that the piezo element is in the threads end of the post and it is intended to be installed threads down which would put it closer to the table, like a Realist vs closer to the strings like most everything else. But, people have installed it either way and I can’t quite determine if we have decided what if anything the audible differences are in one vs the other orientation.
And the manufacturer prefers M8 threads, but he now makes 1/4” for the US market and as near as we can tell, there is not an appreciable sonic difference between the two.
Did I get that about right? Can anyone add anything further on those points without getting into issues of phase, multi-channel pre-amps, various tools and tricks for mixing and blending, or the superiority of mics or ebony adjusters?
Sorry to be cranky, but you keep making me read.
I never read any official information, only this forum.
I've had single sensor m8 threads down installed on two basses. I've never thought about or tried another pickup since.
Two sensors and some sort of mixing whatever is probably great but is it worth the hassle and cost? That's what I tell myself to stop myself from getting a second sensor.
The biggest thing IMHO about this pickup is how realistic the dynamic presentation is. All the notes of the fingerboard are just the same volume as they are acoustically. No ridiculously loud or ridiculously soft notes as with many other pickups.
It also realistically produces the 'hump' of a walking bass note. Its like all other pickups have a built in compressor and the yamahiko doesn't.
The yamahiko isn't microphonic in sound (it's still a piezo!) But it's microphonic in how it reacts if that makes sense? It's like someone eq'd a mic to not sound like a mic but still react the same way although without bleed and feedback of course.
All this is to say that I get that from one sensor on the E string side plugged right into an acoustic image amp. So my guess is 90% of what's possible with the yamahiko is obtained from one sensor.
The guy seemed to specifically design this with m8 threads and installed threads down.
Honestly, I'd say use it as intended. Sure you'll have to pay someone to plug the holes and retap for the larger holes. So what? I had that done with my first bass, no problem and not very expensive if I remember correctly.
And if you get both sides of the bridge by the adjusters plugged and retapped so that what was once a threads up is now threads down, so what? Should only cost a little more.
I know it tempting to get the 1/4" threads and just swap out your current adjusters but there's no guarantee it'll be a perfect fit. I had that happen with a full circle where they went in fine but there must have been some small gap somewhere that created a horrible buzz in the amplified signal (that wasn't audible acoustically).
So I know this is a long reply but my bottom line 2 cents: buy a single sensor m8 threads and have it professionally installed thread side down on the E string side. Plug it into a great acoustic bass amp and never look back!