Long post ahead. Folks who aren't interested in electronics should skip it!
I built my first onboard preamp not quite 30 years ago. I've dabbled in it occasionally ever since.
It's certainly easy to put together an op amp based preamp, especially with the chips available these days. For those just getting started, look at the ON Semiconductor MC33178 - this is the dual op amp chip Carvin uses, and it's got a near ideal combination of low noise and low power consumption at a very reasonable price. Other dual op amps worth looking at are Analog Devices' OP-262 and OP-284.
For the basics, see Walter Jung's classic book "Audio IC Op Amp Applications". Ignore most of the data sheets in the book - modern chips are much more attractive for onboard applications.
Designing a preamp from discrete transistors is definitely harder. It's difficult to balance low power consumption, low noise, and good drive into a highly capacitive load. Low noise and high drive generally mean lots of current, which is a bad idea for a battery powered device.
Whether you use op amps or discretes, these principles apply:
- You don't need a lot of voltage gain. It's often sufficient to use a unity-gain buffer or simple follower circuit.
- The load is primarily capacitative: figure 1000 - 2000 pF is typical, long cables and large pedal boards can be even worse. The resistive load is at worst 5 Kohms if you go straight into a mixer, usually more like 500 K with a proper bass amp. But you need to be able to source and sink a lot of current to drive the cable capacitance.
- The inductive nature of the pickups makes noise current the most crucial spec for the input device. Pickups have their highest impedance of around 100-250 Kohms at resonance, typically 2 to 5 KHz - which, unfortunately, is in the frequency range where the ear is most sensitive. This is the critical region for reducing noise. Voltage noise is most significant in the bass frequencies, where no one will ever hear it! Beware of using bipolar devices (either op amps or discretes) with a low voltage noise spec but a high current noise. This is where the MC33178 wins: it has modest voltage noise but lower current noise than most bipolar op amps. FETs, of course, have negligible current noise.
I hope someone finds this information useful.