My band plays a half-dozen Beatles tunes and my P with flats works great. Tone off or way down. No need for any muting, and I play fingerstyle. As others have said, just make sure to really learn the parts well. My favorite to play is Something.
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
This is my Epiphone Rumblekat. On the used market they typically go for $4-500 and next to an actual Hofner, it’s my favorite for that type of sound. It’s also really great at a lot of other tones too.Hello everyone.
I've been offered the opportunity to play bass in a cover band that also plays some of The Beatles' masterpieces. Therefore, I'd like to achieve a bass sound as close to the original as possible.
Unfortunately, I don't want to spend money on a Hofner violin bass, which I don't like at all (purely for aesthetic reasons; I don't want to offend anyone). So, I've considered a few alternatives: 1) using my Fender Precision with a fretwrap at the bridge and flatwound strings, or 2) buying a used Fender Coronado II bass, or 3) buying a used Epiphone Jack Casady bass, or 4) buying a new Hofner Verythin bass. As for options 2), 3), and 4), there's no opportunity to try these basses before purchasing them.
Which of the above alternatives do you think would be best for my purpose? (please, do not consider money, only the sound!) Thanks!
This! I would get a Rickenbacker 4003S! They're closer in nature to the 4001 that Paul used in the Beatles and later with Wings. They're also less than a regular 4003. People also like them more ergonomically than regular 4003s.I'm no expert, but it is my understanding that most of the second half Beatles bass was recorded with a Rickenbacker 4001
Better looking too.This! I would get a Rickenbacker 4003S! They're closer in nature to the 4001 that Paul used in the Beatles and later with Wings. They're also less than a regular 4003. People also like them more ergonomically than regular 4003s.
I hope I’m not repeating something that has been suggested already. How about this:Hello everyone.
I've been offered the opportunity to play bass in a cover band that also plays some of The Beatles' masterpieces. Therefore, I'd like to achieve a bass sound as close to the original as possible.
Unfortunately, I don't want to spend money on a Hofner violin bass, which I don't like at all (purely for aesthetic reasons; I don't want to offend anyone). So, I've considered a few alternatives: 1) using my Fender Precision with a fretwrap at the bridge and flatwound strings, or 2) buying a used Fender Coronado II bass, or 3) buying a used Epiphone Jack Casady bass, or 4) buying a new Hofner Verythin bass. As for options 2), 3), and 4), there's no opportunity to try these basses before purchasing them.
Which of the above alternatives do you think would be best for my purpose? (please, do not consider money, only the sound!) Thanks!
www.chicagomusicexchange.com
Pretty sure since the Verythins are part of the contemporary series they come with german electronics stock.The Verythin Hofners have a verycool Brown burst flamed Maple, or a 500/5. We know how important pickups and electronics are, so if you needed to you can upgrade to German parts.
Didnt know that, thx.Pretty sure since the Verythins are part of the contemporary series they come with german electronics stock.
OP didn't want a violin bass, sadly. Though those are some cool violin U-basses!I think I would fit in pretty well; flatwounds with humbucker pickups, but a very comfortable 21" scale.
View attachment 7323492
Seriously, only another bass player would even care. The average music listener could care less about tone or what bass you play.Play what you own. Nobody will notice any difference.
This.The last thing anyone listening to a band playing the Beatles will be thinking about is the bass tone. More important is to play the parts accurately. I know this. Ive done a lot of Beatles over the yrs.
Rickenbacker basses are some of the most beautiful in the world! I like the dots and lack of binding on the 4003Ss. I brought up the 4003S because it would look and sound authentic for a Beatles cover band. But the triangle inlays and binding on the regular 4003s are part of that model's beauty. So it's hard to say which model is better looking for me.Better looking too.![]()
Thanks for the suggestion.I hope I’m not repeating something that has been suggested already. How about this:
![]()
Hofner Ignition Pro Club Bass Sunburst
The Ignition (HI) series offers you the chance to own a piece of history even on a tight budget. This model has a fully hollow body combined with Höfner 70's style 'staple' pick-ups to give the authentic Höfner sound. It is of course fitted with the famous Höfner control panel, this has on/off...www.chicagomusicexchange.com
I agree. This is my starting point solution.Rolling the tone down on a p with a sponge mute gets you pretty close to the hofner sound. In my experience a PJ or a J can get closer to the rickenbacker sound.
I read that he used to record the bass track last as he usually played guitar or keys first. Not sure how much truth is in there and certainly not at the earlier sessions.
so who really knows which bass he played on which songs on any particular album.